Reviews for Pizzeria Melrose consistently highlight phenomenal pizza, fresh ingredients, and a welcoming, elegant atmosphere with attentive staff. Diners note generous portions, good value for the quality, and helpful recommendations from servers when deciding on dishes. The menu is praised for variety, including salads, pastas, cannoli, and espresso, with wine often mentioned as decent value. Several experiences advise booking ahead due to the busy pace, and describe the service as friendly, efficient, and above average. A few critiques mention pricing on drinks and a dish note about a sauce being too salty, but these are outweighed by overall satisfaction and the sense of hospitality that makes guests want to return.
Tout était super bon ,peut-être qu'on aurait pris une sauce tomate un peu plus salée pour la pizza mais rien de trop dérangeant. La salade d'endives & le gâteau au chocolat était notre coup de coeur tout simplement incroyable. Le propriétaire était vraiment cool & super sympathique avec les enfants.
We happened by last night & were treated like royalty, the food & service were all terrific. we ordered the Caesar Salad, a Margherita & the homemade Pasta with a creamed mushroom sauce followed up with the Cannoli & an Espresso.
All excellent.
This place was & is absolutely incredible!! I actually wasn't keen on going at first as I noticed it was just pizza no fries no pasta no ice cream but my bf wanted to go so we went & wow!! Was I pleasantly surprised
Originally the owner turned us away for 45mins but then this incredible busboy asked how many we were & told the owner how he can make space for us & within 10mins we were at a table & this busboy went above & beyond. His service was so impressive. The food was also incredible! Portions were generous, &
Prices extremely fair. We had such an amazing experience we were trying to figure out when to go back
The tiramisu so fluffy
The cannoli hard with flavour & the chocolate cake .. wow! Was like fudge
The pizza …so good
Only thing I didn't love was the calamari …sauce.. too salty & very strong olive taste but really not a reason to give this place anything but 10/10
Cesar salad was amazing & this croutons .. wow!! Latte was also delicious!
We were too busy laughing & eating to take photos but had to come here to write a review as
When restaurants are suffering & pockets are tight this place is worth the night out & the wait staff deserve the all the tips
This was an Extremely refreshing restaurant experience
Love Melrose Pizzeria! Fresh, high quality ingredients that brings up your pizza experience to another level. Where else can you find five cheese & spicy honey pizza 😋 Their veal meatballs & fennel salad is also delicious! Pablo, the owner is also an absolute star & always a pleasure to meet!
We've been going to Melrose Pizza since it opened & we still love it all these years later! The pizza & salads are always absolutely delicious & we love the relaxed, homey ambiance. A consistent highlight for us is the staff. Paolo, Marc & Alex always make us feel so welcome & really add to the neighbourhood feel of the place. Excellent service, excellent food -what more could you want?! LOVE IT. Highly recommend.
Mar 7, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
My husband & I have been trying different Pizza Restaurants when ever we travel to bitter cities. Now, we have decided to try one in our neighborhood. Pizzaria Melrose has been at its current location for over 10 years. They serve neopolitain style pizza, pasta, salads, & a few desserts. This time, we were 3, so we got to try 3 different pizzas. First, we started with the Cesar salad. The lettuce was crisp. The dressing was plentiful with a lot of grated cheese on top. Four small slices of bacon were decorativly placed on top. It was very good. We then ordered a Classic pizza, a Gigi pizza, & a Three Meat pizza. The undercarriage of the Classic & Gigi were perfectly cooked & held up to lifting & folding in half. The Tree Meat one, however, was wet & had to be eaten with a fork & knife. They will, for next time, if asked, cook it longer so it won't be soggy. The toppings on all 3 pizzas were very good, making them delicious. Overall, we enjoyed the pizza & will go back. The service was great. Parking was easy considering the location. The atmosphere was noisy, but it's expected for the type of restaurant.
Good Neapolitan pies with good quality ingredients . They definitely care about their product & it shows . Pie was a little underbaked for my taste but I assume most guests would not appreciate a char like I do . Cesar salad was tasty . Good dose of grated cheese & I was impressed that the romaine actually was chilled . Mark was a great host & he assured me that if I request well done next time , it will be looked after . Class act . We will certainly be back
Oct 12, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Excellent restaurant & wonderful experience. We loved the Caesar salad & the fennel salad. The pizzas are amazing. Delicious thin crust, nice tomato sauce, quality ingredients. We tried the Margherita, Classique & NDG. We loved all three, but if I had to choose, the NDG was my favourite. We also shared the homemade rigatoni with sausage & rapini. Delicious! The Margaritas were amazing & paired beautifully with the salads. 😊 For dessert we had the tiramisu & Nutella pizza. The tiramisu was good, but the Nutella pizza was amazing. It even has crushed hazelnuts on top. The restaurant was busy inside & on the terrace. Even so, the service was very good. Attentive & friendly. The prices are very reasonable. Highly recommended!
I got a delivery. One pizza was too soggy, the other one was good. One pizza had chilli & the other one didn't. No utensils for my salad & no napkins. Way too expensive for what you get, disappointed.
Une salade de fenouil divine, une pizza marguerite délicieuse & l'excellent service d Alex, quoi demander de plus! Définitivement un incontournable dans NDG. BRAVO
Jun 15, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
This place is a hidden gem. Don't be a fool & only order the pizza because SO MANY of the other items are incredible Meatballs Braised calamari Salads All incredible Oh, & if you don't like or "get" the staff vibe - sorry to tell you, it's not them, it's you 🤷♀️
