Pizzeria Melrose draws praise for outstanding pizza, fresh ingredients and a warm, elegant atmosphere, with service described as attentive and friendly. Reviewers note generous portions and a solid menu that includes salads, house made pasta, cannoli and tiramisu, and while prices are generally fair, a glass of wine can feel a bit steep. The restaurant is a popular spot for celebrations and groups, often busy and recommended to book in advance, with staff offering helpful suggestions and making guests feel welcome. A few comments mention small issues like a slightly salty tomato sauce or calamari that could be improved, but the overall impression is consistently positive and many say they will return.
Showed to order takeout. One employee told me yes & to wait. The manager turned me around. While leaving I noticed delivery guys were pulling up to take orders. Just a weird experience & now I'm stuck having to find another spot.
I am not used to writing reviews for places but this place made me do it!!!! Worst service possible! Our waiter had a very rude & unprofessional attitude. They took our plates without asking & brought our receipt without asking. Filled our next table's water but not ours. I think they only care about their usuals.
The pizza was mediocre-good crust, but the toppings were nothing special. The sausage on my pizza was overly salty & had a rough texture.
I wouldn't recommend this place & really regret spending our night there. The chains are even better.
The pizzas were medium but the service was awful. The waiter throw the bill on our table & the other one took our plates without asking. When I confronted him instead of apologizing he told me this is the way it is & he let me stay longer!!!even though more than half of the restaurant was empty.
Overall the pizza wasn't worth the price the cocktails were 99% ice & the service was awful.
Apr 12, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Tout était super bon ,peut-être qu'on aurait pris une sauce tomate un peu plus salée pour la pizza mais rien de trop dérangeant. La salade d'endives & le gâteau au chocolat était notre coup de coeur tout simplement incroyable. Le propriétaire était vraiment cool & super sympathique avec les enfants.
Went there to celebrate the year end. The place was packed, which is always a good sign that this is a good place.
The food was delicious & didn't feel we missed on anything. Likewise, if you have any issues deciding you can of course rely on the server's suggestions!
We happened by last night & were treated like royalty, the food & service were all terrific. we ordered the Caesar Salad, a Margherita & the homemade Pasta with a creamed mushroom sauce followed up with the Cannoli & an Espresso.
All excellent.
