Pizzeria Melrose draws praise for outstanding pizza, fresh ingredients and a warm, elegant atmosphere, with service described as attentive and friendly. Reviewers note generous portions and a solid menu that includes salads, house made pasta, cannoli and tiramisu, and while prices are generally fair, a glass of wine can feel a bit steep. The restaurant is a popular spot for celebrations and groups, often busy and recommended to book in advance, with staff offering helpful suggestions and making guests feel welcome. A few comments mention small issues like a slightly salty tomato sauce or calamari that could be improved, but the overall impression is consistently positive and many say they will return.
I am not used to writing reviews for places but this place made me do it!!!! Worst service possible! Our waiter had a very rude & unprofessional attitude. They took our plates without asking & brought our receipt without asking. Filled our next table's water but not ours. I think they only care about their usuals.
The pizza was mediocre-good crust, but the toppings were nothing special. The sausage on my pizza was overly salty & had a rough texture.
I wouldn't recommend this place & really regret spending our night there. The chains are even better.
The pizzas were medium but the service was awful. The waiter throw the bill on our table & the other one took our plates without asking. When I confronted him instead of apologizing he told me this is the way it is & he let me stay longer!!!even though more than half of the restaurant was empty.
Overall the pizza wasn't worth the price the cocktails were 99% ice & the service was awful.
Tout était super bon ,peut-être qu'on aurait pris une sauce tomate un peu plus salée pour la pizza mais rien de trop dérangeant. La salade d'endives & le gâteau au chocolat était notre coup de coeur tout simplement incroyable. Le propriétaire était vraiment cool & super sympathique avec les enfants.
Mar 15, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Went there to celebrate the year end. The place was packed, which is always a good sign that this is a good place.
The food was delicious & didn't feel we missed on anything. Likewise, if you have any issues deciding you can of course rely on the server's suggestions!
We happened by last night & were treated like royalty, the food & service were all terrific. we ordered the Caesar Salad, a Margherita & the homemade Pasta with a creamed mushroom sauce followed up with the Cannoli & an Espresso.
All excellent.
Tout est parfait! De la pizza, fine, croustillante, savoureuse, avec des ingrédients de première qualité au service excellent & super attentionné, gentil & accueillant à l'environnement vraiment élégant & chaleureux. Je me suis senti chez moi. En tant qu'Italien, j'ai été vraiment stupéfait. A essayer absolument ! La pizza N.D.G est fantastique, peut-être grâce au pizzaiolo italo-américain Guido qui a des mains féerées, des années & des années d'expérience & une sympathie & un accueil hors de la façon.
