Restaurant

Pizza Toni

4.2$
Opens Tomorrow at 11:30 am
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday
Pizza Toni Montreal - Menu, Reviews & More January 2026
PizzaPrepared Meals
At pizza toni we serve ny style pizzas and “grandma” style square pies. We believe in sourcing the best ingredients we can in order to make the best possible pizzas. Over our first year of operation we kept the menu tight and simple with only 6 pizzas available. We’ve decided that now is the time to open things up and give the people what they want - more options! So, we’ve added a slew of new toppings for you to enjoy. From organic mushrooms to vegan cheese. Build out your dream pie! Pro tip: we recommend you stick to just a few toppings in order to keep the structure of your pie sound.

Amenities, services & more

Suggested Articles

Best Saint-Henri Restaurants

Foiegwa

3001 Rue Notre-Dame O
(989)

Satay Brothers

3721 Rue Notre Dame O
(836)

Messorem

2233 Rue pitt
(664)

Tropikàl

3426 Rue Notre-Dame O
(814)

Sésame

141 Avenue Atwater
(512)

Events Nearby

Reviews for Pizza Toni

Food
Service
Boost your reputation
on Google*as of 2026-01-014.3 (200+)
5★
67%
4★
10%
3★
5%
2★
16%
1★
2%
Page 4 of 5 - 86 Reviews
D
2.0

As someone originally from Brooklyn, I came in with high hopes-perhaps a bit too high, given the reviews. I do appreciate a thin crust, & they got that part right. However, the overall flavor was quite bland. It felt like the pizza relied heavily on the $2.00 sauces to bring any real taste to the table. Honestly, I would've rated it around 2.5 to 3 stars if it weren't for the price point. For what you get, it just doesn't feel worth it. Respectfully, it's a pass for me.

Apr 5, 2025
Report
on Google
Joe
5.0

So happy to have a place nearby to grab just a slice & the square pizzas are especially amazing. The service has been super friendly every time I've gone so far.

Apr 2, 2025
Report
on Google
Balkirat
5.0

Go to spot for me & all the people that come to our recording studio :)

Mar 29, 2025
Report
on Google
Robert
5.0

Another good discovery on Notre Dame W is Pizza Toni. Recommended by a Lachine Canal resident,the restaurant is conveniently located on Notre Dame between the St.Remi tunnel & De Courcelles. This branch of Pizza Toni is open only four months & along with the original branch is an extension of the owner of the successful Falafel Yoni chain (3) Serving NY style pizza, the result is a thin crusted,not oily,very moist, mild cheese pizza that is very light & delicious. While I have never tried sauces to augment any pizza, I capitulated. Both the spicy honey & the ranch dressings (sour creme /dill) were great recommendations. Pizzas range from $25 to$35 per pizza. While not cheap,I am surprised to say that their designer pies were well worthwhile Bravo Yoni & his partners.

Mar 28, 2025
Report
on Google
Luca
5.0

Bonne musique
Commandez une pizza entière, je recommande

Mar 22, 2025
Report
on Google
Leonardo
5.0

Best pizza in Montreal. Period.

Mar 22, 2025
Report
on Google
Ryan
5.0

Best new pizzeria in Montreal. I stopped by here today & got a slice of the Sweet Cherry Pie & a slice of the Pepperoni. The sweet cherry was spicy & sweet which went super well with the goats cheese & cherry tomatoes. The cashier recommended the grandma pie, which I hadn't tried before & I almost like it more than the regular round ones. Chewy but crispy & it was soooo cheesy. Definitely happy they decided to open in St Henri.

Mar 21, 2025
Report
on Google
Matthew
5.0

That vodka pepperoni is sooo good!!!

Mar 21, 2025
Report
on Google
S
5.0

Amazing pizza! Only good NY style spot I've found in Quebec. This location is so much bigger than the Mile End one so it was nice to be able to sit down with our food. Will be back!

Mar 21, 2025
Report
on Google
Dan
5.0

I was so happy when I found out Pizza Toni was opening up on the west side of the city. Their Square Pep & mushroom pizzas are to DIE for. Incredibly flavourful pizza sauce, crispy yet pillowy dough, & their dipping sauces are bomb. I highly recommend this place for pizza take out, probably one of my favourites.

Mar 7, 2025
Report
on Google
Thong
4.0

Like it ,good crust & taste

Mar 5, 2025
Report
on Google
John
5.0

Great slice options, service & dine in area.

Mar 3, 2025
Report
on Google
Jessica
5.0

Top 3 pizzas in MTL. It's sooooo good!!! The pepperoni is a must but they're honestly all good. Don't forget to eat it with spicy honey & the white dipping sauce 🤤

Feb 28, 2025
Report
on Google
Victor
5.0

Le meilleur pizza dans le coin !

Feb 22, 2025
Report
on Google
Alexandra
5.0

Best. Pizza. Ever. Our go to ALWAYS. so happy they're closer to home now 🙌🏻

Feb 10, 2025
Report
on Google
Zacharie
5.0

Great staff, great pizza, friendly + free dipping sauce to try with the crust.

Great spot. A must try.

Feb 8, 2025
Report
on Google
Marco
2.0

overpriced & Dry like Toni's mom

Feb 5, 2025
Report
on Google
J
5.0

Always heard great things about Toni's Pizza, glad they opened one up in Saint-Henri because it did not disappoint. Delicious pizzas, really nice interior decoration & great service! Highly recommend

Feb 3, 2025
Report
on Google
Maria
5.0

Great pizza & friendly service! Tasty crust, yummy toppings & reasonably priced. (We tried the all dressed & mushroom) They opened not long ago, so we were expecting that pizza would take longer than promised, but was ready upon pickup at promised time. We will be enjoying their again. RECOMMEND!!!

Feb 2, 2025
Report
on Google
Mathieu
5.0

Hands down one of the very best pizza in town. So glad they open that new location.

Jan 31, 2025
Report
on Google