Pizza Toni

Matthew

5.0

Great pies by great guys & gals

Filip

5.0

Classic new york style pie. No flop at all, thin well done & crispy. Absolutely no complaints about this, everything was perfect & talk about a great ratio for all the toppings.

One of the best pies in Montreal hands down. I give this an 8.8 that's a review.

Jesse

2.0

I really love the pizza here & at the other location & it always hits the mark in terms of flavour. Square pep is my favourite slice in the city & it isn't even close.

My one issue with this location in particular is that I've come multiple times for dinner around 6-6:30 on Sundays & have found the variety & availability of slices to be extremely lacking. Came today & there were no pizzas in the case, only 1 round pepperoni pizza available for slices. This isn't the first time I've come & seen the display case basically empty. Obviously a testament to people loving the pizza & many full pie orders coming through but very disappointed that this has happened multiple times. Staff however have been super nice every single time when it happens but it's just happened too often unfortunately

GMA

3.0

Pizza Toni run tonight.
Two 18' pies = $80. Inflation said'ciao.'

Pickup time: 1 hour.

Reality:'Come back in 15.'

Eight cooks in the kitchen, two people eating inside, & somehow my basil still came out crispy like a campfire marshmallow.

Honey + sesame crust was great… the rest? Tough, burnt, & not giving what the reviews promised.

We still ate it, but joy was not included.

Henry

2.0

Pizza toni what happened? I went in today for some slices, & I was absolutely astounded by the price 15$ for two slices no drink, no dip, no parm. Just a dirty chili flake shaker & some napkins. I mean fair enough when you have 9! People on staff flipping pies & tweaking out but comon?!?! Ridonkulous. (Edit) saying it's 2026 is an amazing response. good job I was un aware of the year. & yes I stand by the melon review. That pizza was fresh, delicious & I seem to remember it didn't cost 15$ for two dry slices of pie. It may be the same pizza under your brand but the difference was extreme. Jacking up the prices & putting out a worse product expecting people to not say anything is crazy. Always blame the year not your approach, excellent strategy for growth.

Nicholas

5.0

true montreal vibe

best pie outside of ny

Ivan

5.0

Great pizza spot in St-Henri!

The quality of the pizza was very good. I especially like the classic cheese pizza slice. The undercarriage is thin & has a good crisp. Pizza is not too floppy, pretty firm. Cheese & sauce were very good too. If you want the freshest pizza, I would recommend ordering & full pie & not ordering the individual slices which are in display.

The Triple-P square slice was good, but not my favorite. The dough wasn't as fluffy as I would have liked for a deep dish.

The price for slices is pretty expensive though coming out to ~6$/ slice. So if you want the freshest pizza & the vest value for money I would recommend ordering & full pie over the individual slices which are on display.

Overall, this is a fantastic pizza spot & I would definitely recommend. Next time, I'll try the vodka pepperoni.

Woody

5.0

Just tried a piece of pepperoni pizza & it was delicious. Next time I'm in the area definitely picking up a pizza.

Zachary

5.0

Haven't been there yet but order online only
But the pie is delicious, great portion & tasty 120% recommended. The honey garlic pizza is my fav also the Vegeterian was deli deli. The ranch dip huufffff good good goof 😋😋

Taylor

5.0

Came from out of town, & was referred… so glad we were. This pizza was the truth, the vibes were immaculate, even had some ranch & garlic sauces to dip these bad boys into. The brewski was an added bonus. Get the sweet cherry pie, you won't regret. Top notch spot, would go again, & you should too. Thanks fellas!