Monday

11:30 am - 9 pm

Tuesday

11:30 am - 9 pm

Wednesday

11:30 am - 9 pm

Thursday

11:30 am - 9 pm

Friday

11:30 am - 10 pm

Saturday

11:30 am - 10 pm

Sunday

11:30 am - 9 pm

About

Pizza Toni is a premier destination for authentic, hand-crafted pizzas, delivering a superior Italian-inspired dining experience right in the heart of the city. Their commitment to quality begins with fresh, high-grade ingredients, forming the foundation for a diverse menu featuring classic and signature creations. Patrons can expect expertly baked pizzas with perfectly crisp crusts and generous toppings, showcasing a dedication to traditional techniques and vibrant flavors. The establishment offers a welcoming atmosphere perfect for casual get-togethers and family meals, ensuring a consistently satisfying meal for all who visit. Every dish is prepared with precision, reflecting a passion for delivering exceptional pizza.

Reviews for Pizza Toni

Food

Service

on Google4.4 (300+)

*as of 2026-08-01

4.4 293 ratings

5★

73%

4★

3★

2★

1★

Write your review

Reviews often mention

Display All pizza(183) slice(27) recommend(20) crust(19) sauce(16) spicy(15) honey(15) pepperoni(13) pie(13) crispy(11) style(11) garlic(10)

Review Summary

Pizza Toni is widely regarded as one of the best pizza spots in Montreal, frequently praised for its authentic New York style pies featuring thin, perfectly crispy crusts and high quality fresh ingredients. Many patrons highlight the spicy honey pepperoni and vodka sauce options as standout choices, often recommending the addition of their popular dipping sauces. While the majority of guests appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and friendly, attentive staff, some feedback notes inconsistencies in food quality, occasional long wait times, and issues with slice availability or cleanliness in the dining area. Despite mixed opinions on pricing and rare instances of less than ideal texture, the overall consensus remains highly positive, with many customers considering it a must visit destination in the Saint Henri neighborhood.

Page 1 of 2 - 15 Reviews

5.0

Pizza Toni has officially become our favourite pizza in Montreal. We order it regularly, & whenever we have the time to pick it up & enjoy a slice straight out of the oven, it's absolutely worth the trip.

The standouts for us are the Pep d'Ail with its fantastic sesame seed crust & the SGHP (Spicy Garlic Honey Pepperoni). Both are outstanding & completely different from one another.

Everything just works. The crust has the perfect balance of crispness & chew, the toppings are well thought out, & the flavours are balanced without feeling heavy.

The only thing I'd mention is that I personally always order extra cheese because I find they're a little light on some of the toppings. That's completely a matter of preference, though, & certainly hasn't stopped us from becoming regular customers.

Montreal has no shortage of great pizza, but Pizza Toni has earned the top spot for our family. It's consistently excellent, & we'll happily keep coming back.

Jul 26, 2026

on Google

Nico

5.0

SpicyHoneyGarlicPep is still the best :)

Jul 14, 2026

on Google

Samuel

5.0

I ordered it through door dash, first time eating their pizzas. Got the spicy honey pep, one of the best pizzas I've eaten period. The crisp, the quality of the dough, the sauce, the freshness of that basil. Even my wife who is not a fan of pizza (yeah I know weird right?) loved it.

Jun 20, 2026

on Google

Jessica

5.0

We really enjoyed the square pepperoni pizza, it was amazing! We got it with the spicy honey dip. Cute spot, lots of places to sit.

May 4, 2026

on Google

Camille

5.0

Excellente pizza 🍕 Notre préférée : la Spicy Honey Garlic Pep, un vrai coup de coeur ! Très bon service malgré l'achalandage, le staff est super sympathique & attentioné lorsque l'attente est plus longue que prévu lors d'une commande passée d'avance en ligne. On recommande sans hésiter !

Mar 11, 2026

on Google

Suzie

5.0

Best pizza in town !!! Recommend the spicy garlic honey pep 💛 garlic sauce is a must!

Mar 3, 2026

on Google

Paskal666

5.0

Take out une 14' SpicyHoneyGarlicPep, excellente pizza & service ,la sauce marinara se marie bien avec l'ail & le côté spicy, la croûte légèrement crispy était juste👌.... ⭐4.7

Mar 3, 2026

on Google

Greg

5.0

Hands down best pizza spot in the city. Always consistent, flavourful & crisp. The best part of everything is the service. The entire team is always extremely friendly & helpful. Never not smiling.
Today I had an absolute stellar service from Edward. You can tell he loves his job. He offered me the spicy honey on the house, so I could taste it. Great pizza will bring a customer back again…..staff members like Edward will keep customers for a lifetime.

Mar 1, 2026

on Google

Arianne

5.0

Best pizza I've tried to date in Montreal. This was the spicy pep pizza. Amazing

Nov 11, 2025

on Google

4.0

Got the SHGP (spicy honey garlic pepperoni). Thin crust but not dry, super flavourful. A little bit on the sweet side cause of the honey. But still really good!

Jun 27, 2025

on Google

Pizza Toni

Authentic Detroit-style square pizza brings a crispy, cheesy edge to the heart of Saint-Henri.

LocationError?

About

Details

Mentioned in:

The Best Pizza in Montreal

Restaurants in Saint-HenriView More

Satay Brothers

Foiegwa

Messorem

Lucille's Au Marché

Greenspot

Reviews for Pizza Toni

Review Summary