Monday

11:30 am - 9 pm

Tuesday

11:30 am - 9 pm

Wednesday

11:30 am - 9 pm

Thursday

11:30 am - 9 pm

Friday

11:30 am - 10 pm

Saturday

11:30 am - 10 pm

Sunday

11:30 am - 9 pm

About

Pizza Toni is a premier destination for authentic, hand-crafted pizzas, delivering a superior Italian-inspired dining experience right in the heart of the city. Their commitment to quality begins with fresh, high-grade ingredients, forming the foundation for a diverse menu featuring classic and signature creations. Patrons can expect expertly baked pizzas with perfectly crisp crusts and generous toppings, showcasing a dedication to traditional techniques and vibrant flavors. The establishment offers a welcoming atmosphere perfect for casual get-togethers and family meals, ensuring a consistently satisfying meal for all who visit. Every dish is prepared with precision, reflecting a passion for delivering exceptional pizza.

Reviews for Pizza Toni

Food

Service

on Google4.4 (300+)

*as of 2026-08-01

4.3 291 ratings

5★

73%

4★

3★

2★

1★

Write your review

Reviews often mention

Display All pizza(183) slice(27) recommend(20) crust(19) sauce(16) spicy(15) honey(15) pie(13) pepperoni(12) crispy(11) style(11) garlic(10)

Review Summary

Pizza Toni is widely regarded as one of the best pizza spots in Montreal, frequently praised for its authentic New York style pies featuring thin, perfectly crispy crusts and high quality fresh ingredients. Many patrons highlight the spicy honey pepperoni and vodka sauce options as standout choices, often recommending the addition of their popular dipping sauces. While the majority of guests appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and friendly, attentive staff, some feedback notes inconsistencies in food quality, occasional long wait times, and issues with slice availability or cleanliness in the dining area. Despite mixed opinions on pricing and rare instances of less than ideal texture, the overall consensus remains highly positive, with many customers considering it a must visit destination in the Saint Henri neighborhood.

Page 1 of 2 - 16 Reviews

Mathilde

3.0

Crispy crust but lacks taste. The square pizza are better than the slices as they have more tomato sauce & so are more tasty. Not sure I would return.

Aug 1, 2026

on Google

Samuel

5.0

I ordered it through door dash, first time eating their pizzas. Got the spicy honey pep, one of the best pizzas I've eaten period. The crisp, the quality of the dough, the sauce, the freshness of that basil. Even my wife who is not a fan of pizza (yeah I know weird right?) loved it.

Jun 20, 2026

on Google

Júlia

5.0

I was just in New York & ate at L'industrie (considered the best pizza there right now). THIS IS BETTER!!! I couldn't believe myself either…but it is. Insanely tasty. Get the garlic sauce too.

May 2, 2026

on Google

Rocko

4.0

Decided to try a slice at this sparsely decorated space. I had a slice that was heated on the spot. The crust was perfectly crisp. The sauce was great. It reminded me of a place in Verdun that made NY pizza that closed. Delicious pizza.

May 2, 2026

on Google

Suzie

5.0

Best pizza in town !!! Recommend the spicy garlic honey pep 💛 garlic sauce is a must!

Mar 3, 2026

on Google

Paskal666

5.0

Take out une 14' SpicyHoneyGarlicPep, excellente pizza & service ,la sauce marinara se marie bien avec l'ail & le côté spicy, la croûte légèrement crispy était juste👌.... ⭐4.7

Mar 3, 2026

on Google

Jann

5.0

OH MY GOD BEST PIZZA & MAYBE EVEN DINING EXPERIENCE IN MONTREAL NO JOKE GET THAT VODKA SAUCE. I WILL BE IN SOON WITH A CRAZY CUSTOM ORDER

Jan 21, 2026

on Google

Ivan

5.0

Great pizza spot in St-Henri!

The quality of the pizza was very good. I especially like the classic cheese pizza slice. The undercarriage is thin & has a good crisp. Pizza is not too floppy, pretty firm. Cheese & sauce were very good too. If you want the freshest pizza, I would recommend ordering & full pie & not ordering the individual slices which are in display.

The Triple-P square slice was good, but not my favorite. The dough wasn't as fluffy as I would have liked for a deep dish.

The price for slices is pretty expensive though coming out to ~6$/ slice. So if you want the freshest pizza & the vest value for money I would recommend ordering & full pie over the individual slices which are on display.

Overall, this is a fantastic pizza spot & I would definitely recommend. Next time, I'll try the vodka pepperoni.

Dec 2, 2025

on Google

Alexandre

5.0

Love at first bite! Première fois chez Pizza Toni pour moi & c'est une des meilleures pizzas que j'ai mangé à vie… La pâte est franchement légère, la sauce est vraiment délicieuse & les garnitures fraîches sont juste assez abondantes pour une pizza mince style New York… Le poivron rouge rôti & les champignons marinés font toute la différence dans la All-Dressed. Highly recommend! 😛❤?👍

Jul 21, 2025

on Google

Taylor

5.0

Came from out of town, & was referred… so glad we were. This pizza was the truth, the vibes were immaculate, even had some ranch & garlic sauces to dip these bad boys into. The brewski was an added bonus. Get the sweet cherry pie, you won't regret. Top notch spot, would go again, & you should too. Thanks fellas!

Jun 21, 2025

on Google

Pizza Toni

Authentic Detroit-style square pizza brings a crispy, cheesy edge to the heart of Saint-Henri.

LocationError?

About

Details

Mentioned in:

The Best Pizza in Montreal

Restaurants in Saint-HenriView More

Satay Brothers

Foiegwa

Messorem

Lucille's Au Marché

Greenspot

Reviews for Pizza Toni

Review Summary