Pizza Select earns high marks for a crust that is crispy and chewy with a rich sauce and fresh toppings, and many reviewers say it is among the best pizza around. The menu variety includes North American and Quebecoise style pizzas, with generous toppings and standout options like saffron meatballs, while the service is repeatedly described as friendly, fast, and reliable by a family run staff. Takeout is common and dine in is available in a tiny space with a note that no bathroom is on site, but customers appreciate the value, hot pizzas, and occasional promotions on select days. Overall the place is seen as a reliable go to for pizza in the West Island, delivering consistently fresh dough and quality ingredients.
If you live in the West Island & you want Montreal style pizza, This place is it. I tried them for the first time ordering wings & a Quebecoise, to test the bacon & peperoni & I can tell you, it was way better than expected. The crust was made with quality flour, the sauce was also excellent, home made, & the bacon was thick quality bacon, not the paper thin garbage you find on most of these pizzas & the Mozzarella was fresh & quality also, very important..The wings were good, standard deep fried with two sauces to go along with them, all in all I can say that they will be my go to parlour for North American pizza...one of the owners being Persian, they even have meatballs with Safran on the menu, I will br trying those next. Husband & wife team running the place, & they work hard to produce a quality product with a menu for all tastes. Give them a try.
Feb 8, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Stopped by on a whim, very happy we did, kids loved the pizzas, crispy crust, perfect gluten, with crust that bounces back after you bite into it, great service, fast & efficient, definitely recommend 😋
Delicious pizza, very fresh, crust was amazing, tomato sauce was very tasty & not acidic. The staff was more than kind, welcoming, & helpful. Will definitely come again!
The best pizza around, the dough ( crust) to die for.
I recommend everyone eats here.
Owners Paiemen & Jamie & staff are awesome.
Just Great people.
A definite must.
Decided to try Pizza Select as it's close to home & wanted to support a new local business. Pizza had really good sauce & crust. We had an all dressed & cheese. Good amount of toppings with the right mix of cheese. Everyone was happy with their selection. We ordered on a Tuesday night so qualified for their promotion so it was good value.
May 20, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Wowza!!! We ordered the all dressed & it's sooo good! It came pipping hot, so FRESH!! It's really hard to find fresh pizza that tastes this good! Absolutely delicious! Crust is perfect & toppings/sauce & cheese are delicious! Undercarriage in some slices were a bit wet due to the sauce but worth eating right away. If it's a little less sauce it'll be 10/10. Right now all dressed 12' has 8 pieces 8.9/10. Definitely a must try!🤌🏻
If you're not eating at Pizza Select, you're missing out. The crust is perfectly crispy yet soft, & the sauce? Pure magic- savoury, & addictive. The toppings are next level-creative without being over the top-& every bite is a flavour bomb. But honestly, you can't go wrong with anything on the menu. The vibe is cozy, the staff is friendly, & you'll feel like you've found your new pizza home. Seriously, stop reading & get there. You won't regret it.
