Reviews portray Ciccio's as a standout Italian sandwich spot in Montreal, with bread and ingredients highlighted for quality and flavor, especially the muffuletta, porchetta, caprese, and prosciutto sandwiches. The bread is consistently praised for crisp crust and soft interior, the meats and cheeses feel fresh, and the signature ciccio sauce adds a creamy tang. The vibe is retro yet cozy, with limited seating and a preference for takeout, while the service is often warm and attentive but occasionally could be more welcoming or consistent. Some criticism exists over price versus portion size and occasional menu stability with items like muffuletta sometimes selling out; nonetheless the overall experience is described as enjoyable and memorable, making it a must visit for Italian sandwiches in Old Montreal with many reviewers planning return trips to try more items and desserts like pistachio tiramisu and espresso drinks.
I've had 4 sandwiches here. I had high expectations because of the hype & the price. Unfortunately, I don't think that the offerings are delivering flavor & experience that match the price point.
All the staff I have interacted with have been friendly. The orders are prepared at a good pace. I just want more from a $20 sandwich.
Ciccio, c'est notre café & SANDWICH coup de coeur. L'ambiance est chaleureuse, le café est toujours délicieux, & j'adore y aller avec mon copain. C'est devenu notre petit rituel à deux, un endroit où on prend le temps, on discute, on rigole…
Un vrai cocon où chaque moment partagé devient un bon souvenir. On y retourne toujours avec plaisir !
Magnifique petit resto & surtout excellente sandwich italienne avec ingrédients de qualités. Le staff est super gentil & accueillant.
nouvelle adresse sur McGill & tout aussi bon (muffuletta) & la créma di café est une merveille en bouche!
I got their Muffuletta, cappuccino, & pistachio tiramisu & it was the best meal I had in Montreal. I'm a big fan of Italian sandwiches & their New Orleans version of this was truly phenomenal - crispy bread, just the right amount of preserved veggies, quality meats, & a thick slab of mozzarella (which is a slight ding in the aesthetics b/c I couldn't fit the sandwich in my mouth). I will spread the gospel of Ciccio's upon my return & pray they open in NYC.
Ciccio's is all about getting back to basics-with real style. The quality of the food stands out right away. The vibe is awesome, & the staff are super chill & friendly.
You have to try the porchetta-thin slices of perfectly seasoned pork roast, fresh cheese, & their signature mayo. It's seriously delicious.
Ciccio's is one of the best classic sandwich shops in Old Montréal. The Mortazza sandwich was amazing! I was craving a breakfast sando & it totally hit the spot. I also tried their chocolate chip cookie, which was soft, chewy, & not too sweet. Would love to return to try other items on their menu including the Muffuletta. Staffing were kind & delivered prompt service. Nice stylish interiors with retro charm. They have counter & window seating (although limited). The vibez here are comfy yet relaxed. Definitely a must visit for a quick bite.
