Reviews portray Ciccio's as a standout Italian sandwich spot in Montreal, with bread and ingredients highlighted for quality and flavor, especially the muffuletta, porchetta, caprese, and prosciutto sandwiches. The bread is consistently praised for crisp crust and soft interior, the meats and cheeses feel fresh, and the signature ciccio sauce adds a creamy tang. The vibe is retro yet cozy, with limited seating and a preference for takeout, while the service is often warm and attentive but occasionally could be more welcoming or consistent. Some criticism exists over price versus portion size and occasional menu stability with items like muffuletta sometimes selling out; nonetheless the overall experience is described as enjoyable and memorable, making it a must visit for Italian sandwiches in Old Montreal with many reviewers planning return trips to try more items and desserts like pistachio tiramisu and espresso drinks.
I ate here in November on a rainy day. I won't dwell on the quality of the food, which wasn't bad (although, being Italian, I have eaten better panini in my life), but on the treatment I received. My plan was to eat there & stay to study for a bit, waiting for the rain to stop. I was not allow to do. Immediately after finishing my panini, about 15 minutes after arriving, I was asked from the one who seemed to be the owner of the place, to leave, even though the place wasn't so busy & outside was still raining.
I felt uncomfortable, I recommend the place only if you want to be treated rudely!!
Best sandwiches in town. More Italian style. It's must try. Honestly i should keep this place a secret. I much place to sit as it is more of a take out place but if you're lucky you get can a booth. They also have great clothing.
Fantastic, authentic Italian Deli. You'd have to travel to Rome to get a better sandwich, dessert or coffee. Excellent food, plus a neighborhood steeped old world charm. Perfetta service too!
I was pleasantly surprised by how cozy & retro the restaurant feels. The sandwiches were really tasty, & the salad was superb! Service felt a little bit off, but the rest outweighted it.
Totally recommended if you're around the Old Port.
Sep 23, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
I got their Muffuletta, cappuccino, & pistachio tiramisu & it was the best meal I had in Montreal. I'm a big fan of Italian sandwiches & their New Orleans version of this was truly phenomenal - crispy bread, just the right amount of preserved veggies, quality meats, & a thick slab of mozzarella (which is a slight ding in the aesthetics b/c I couldn't fit the sandwich in my mouth). I will spread the gospel of Ciccio's upon my return & pray they open in NYC.
Jun 1, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Neat little cafe with a somewhat retro-Italian atmosphere. The sandwiches are their prime offering for food. Pricy but not unexpected given the area. The quality definitely hit. Service was also pleasing, I appreciated that the girl asked how I liked the food afterwards.
Dec 19, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Un vero panino italiano! I was passing by & got caught by the cozy & charming place to only ecounter a great sandwich for breakfast & excellent coffee, the team at Ciccio's is very warming, not to mention the incredible taste & quality of the food, the muffuletta sandwich is something you should definitely try if you want to be transported to Italy.
Great Italian sandwich in Old Montreal. Very welcoming vibe - elements gave it a modern old school diner feel with a bright atmosphere. Staff were very friendly. Ordered the caprese sandwich & it was excellent. All the ingredients tasted fresh & premium. Loved the fresh mozzarella & prosciutto that paired very nice with the Pesto. The bread was also really good. It had some crunch but was soft so it was not hard to bite. Overall, everything just went so well together. Would definitely go back to try another sandwich & a drink.
VERY good sandwich. It's on the pricey end, but that is because it's quality products. Also, expect to wait a bit, but again, it's because everything is made to order. Highly recommended if you like high-quality Italian deli sandwiches.
Their Italian sandwiches are to die for, burnt & full of Italian passion. 8 inches of baked bread filled with meat & cheese, with exclusive sauce, perfect to stimulate the taste of ingredients, really delicious
