Reviews portray Basilico Pizza and Pasta as a cozy Italian spot on Nuns' Island with wood fired pizzas and tasty pastas. Guests describe a warm, inviting atmosphere and friendly, attentive service, with a standout hostess who helps make each visit special and a team that takes care of diners well. Pizza is often praised, especially the margherita, and the pastas, such as carbonara, are noted for freshness and al dente texture, with some diners calling the pizza among the best in Montreal. Several remarks advise making a reservation during busy periods because the place can be crowded and noisy, but the overall experience is seen as worth a visit. A few comments mention that the pizzas have become more average since the original pizzaiolo left, yet many continue to enjoy the meal along with dessert options like panna cotta and Nutella pizza.
We came with no reservation last Friday just to see how it is & they found us a seat in between other reservations!
We only had about 1.5hr but it was more than enough as the food came so fast & the waitresses were super prompt in everything.
Aranza's recommendations were all good - we had carbonara pasta (the sauce is real diff) & Rustica pizza, with a nice fruity cocktail & beer. She was also very kind & sweet to us.
Basilico Pizza & Pasta is fantastic! Authentic Italian flavors, perfectly cooked pasta, & delicious, fresh pizzas make every meal memorable. The staff is friendly & attentive, & the atmosphere is cozy & inviting. Highly recommend for anyone craving quality Italian cuisine & a wonderful dining experience!
Mar 18, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Excellent, les pâtes parfaites & toujours'al dente', la bonne pizza, le service efficace & courtois, les prix honnêtes. Heidi nous fait toujours rire & passer des très agréables moments avec son éternel sourire!
Great pizza , tomato sauce needs improvement but great chef & staff we love Heidi. She is the best. We come for her . Amazing service & always happy to come a have a great experience.
I always order their margherita pizza, one of the best pizzas ive had in montreal. Our waitress (shoutout Aranza!) was so nice & helpful throughout the night. 10/10 experience every time
Jan 17, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Pizzas used to be excellent, but since the original pizzaiolo had left, the pizzas are not as good anymore; they are now kind of average'american' pizza.
Pizzas used to be excellent, but since the original pizzaiolo had left, the pizzas are not as good anymore; they are now kind of average'american' pizza. Make sure you make a reservation, else you won't have a table! The place is quite noisy with densely placed tables & people often talk loudly .
Je suis allé dans ce restaurant avec mon épouse & nous avons tout adoré. L'accueil était chaleureux, & les pizzas, authentiquement italiennes. Fermez les yeux en les dégustant, & vous voilà transporté en Italie. Le dessert, une panna cotta aux fraises, était tout simplement excellent.
Basilico Pizza & Pasta is a cozy Italian eatery nestled on Nuns' Island, Montreal, offering a delightful selection of pizzas & pastas. Guests often praise their wood-fired pizzas for their exceptional taste. The pasta dishes, particularly the carbonara, are also highly recommended. The restaurant provides a warm & inviting atmosphere, complemented by friendly & attentive service. For dessert, the Nutella pizza is a popular choice among patrons. Whether you're a local or a visitor, Basilico Pizza & Pasta offers a satisfying dining experience that captures the essence of Italian cuisine.
The absolute best Carbonara outside of Rome! Delicious cannoli & very friendly service. The Nutella pizza for dessert is also a great choice. Definitely recommend for lunch or dinner.
Oct 5, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Excellente pizza! C'était notre première visite & le personnel était agréable avec nous. Aucun problème pour se garer même si c'était une soirée très achalandée.
Parfait pour les familles! Super service Ma lasagne est délicieuse & les enfants adorent la pizza classique avec ajout de prosciutto & la salade César! merci beaucoup
This hidden gem has some of the best fried calamari in the city. I definite must try Restaurant with a beautiful delicious authentic Italian woodburning pizza. Excellent service & Zen atmosphere Absolutely delicious
