Best American Restaurants in Old Montreal (2026) - Reviews & Menus

Explore 3 local dining options, sorted by relevance. You can also view the highest rated or explore the full list.

The Keg Steakhouse + Bar

Old Montreal

Steakhouse Seafood/Fish American Grill Contemporary/Modern Canadian

Review Summary

The Keg Steakhouse + Bar in Old Montreal is generally described as a dependable steakhouse with consistently well cooked steaks and friendly, attentive service, offering a warm, upscale atmosphere with a cozy bar area that many diners find ideal for drinks or happy hour. Dishes frequently praised include filet mignon, New York strip, rib steak, côte de boeuf, and seafood like lobster tail, with classics such as Caesar salad, twice baked potatoes, garlic mashed potatoes, and the Billy Miner Pie dessert getting frequent nods. The ambience is noted as welcoming, with beautiful brick interiors and dim lighting, though some guests mention loudness, noise from TVs, or cooler seats near entrances. Service is often highlighted for knowledge, allergy awareness, and timing, while a few reviews mention reservation hiccups, occasional slow or imperfect executions, or meals arriving at room temperature. Overall, The Keg is seen as a solid, value-conscious choice for steak lovers in Montreal, with many guests planning to return and recommending reservations, especially for celebrations or special occasions.View restaurant profile

Order

Romies

American Bistro

Opens Today at 5:30 pm

(329)

Old Montreal

American Bistro Burgers

Mentioned in: The Best Spots for Dirty Martinis in Montreal Hot Spots to Try Now for Your Girls' Night Out in Montreal View More

Review Summary

Romies is described as a stylish, vibey spot in Old Montreal with a beautiful terrace that many reviews say is perfect for dates or celebrations. The service is often praised for being friendly and attentive, though a few experiences mention slow or inconsistent service, especially on busy nights. The food is generally regarded as delicious and well presented, with frequent highlights including fried zucchini, pasta alla zozzona, crudo, focaccia, rib eye, and a standout dessert scene featuring chocolate cake or blackout cake. Some readers feel the prices are high for the portions and value, and a number of dishes arrive not as hot as expected or can be a little heavy on richness. The ambiance, decor, and open kitchen vibe create a memorable experience that many say elevates the meal, though the noise level and crowds can be a downside for some. Across reviews, Romies is seen as a place with strong positives in food and atmosphere, and a willingness to return for the terrace, cocktails, and signature dishes, while the occasional critique centers on price, consistency and service during peak times.View restaurant profile

Lattuca Barbecue

Authentic Wood-Fired Barbecue!

Opens Today at 5 pm

(550)

Old Montreal

BBQ American Smokehouse Comfort Food

Mentioned in: American BBQ and Smokehouse in Montreal: Must-Tries

Review Summary

Taken together, reviews depict Lattuca Barbecue as a standout Texas style smokehouse in Montreal with generous portions and a focus on tender, smoky meats like brisket and beef ribs that many visitors consider among the best outside Texas. The sides such as mac and cheese, coleslaw, and baked beans are frequently praised for flavor, though a few comments note issues with temperature or consistency and some meat being slightly dry or overly salty. A verbally delivered menu and the absence of a fixed menu are repeatedly mentioned, along with occasional service flaws, wait times, and higher prices, especially for sharing platters. The atmosphere is described as warm, casual, and welcoming with attentive staff and a clear passion for pit cooking, drawing locals and visitors from far away who often say the experience is worth the trip. Overall, the brisket and beef ribs emerge as the standout items that keep guests returning, even as some visits remind that peak times can impact service and value.View restaurant profile