These reviews paint Sicily Pizza as a place where a really delicious vegetarian pizza stands out, along with a menu that includes butter chicken naan and fried chicken, generous portions and very reasonable prices making it a frequent stop and one of Montreal's favorites; the pizza, poutine, and chicken are consistently praised and the staff and owner are described as friendly, though some say service could be better; a notable theme is changes after a new owner, with higher prices and a drop in quality, thinner crust and less sauce, but overall flavors remain appealing and fried chicken and poutine get strong praise despite occasional chewiness of a slice.