Gentile Pizza Parlour

H.

3.0

I had a pizza here - the ingredients were good quality, but there just wasn't enough cheese (I'm not exaggerating). The pizza turned out quite dry. I usually love a crispy pizza, but this one just missed that mark.
That said, the dough itself was well prepared & you can tell they use fresh, quality ingredients. Just don't expect authentic Italian-style pizza. Considering the prices & the good ingredients they have access to, I think they could do a better job overall.
On the positive side, the staff was absolutely lovely & the service was excellent - very friendly & attentive.

Oct 29, 2025

on Google

Alessia

5.0

I've been to GPP before for lunch/dinner & always enjoyed it the food, the ambiance & the service. I therefore chose to celebrate a milestone birthday here. We were 25+ people & we were hosted very warmly. When the last service ended, we had the restaurant to ourselves. Anthony, the owner, always checked in to ensure everyone was enjoying themselves & that everything was going smoothly. Anna, our waitress, was a sweetheart. She brought impeccable service & lots of enthusiasm, which was so appreciated. We also had Brando be our DJ for the evening & his music & skills were incredible. My guests & I had an absolutely fun & fabulous evening. Everyone only had great things to say. Not to mention, the food is great - fresh, quality ingredients. I love GPP & would recommend it to anyone - whether for a casual dinner or a private party! Thank you to the GPP team for making my birthday so fun & special!

Mar 31, 2025

on Google

Greg

5.0

Had a great time at Gentile Pizza Parlor last saturday evening with my friend. I particularily enjoyed the cozy & feel good vibe of the place. The decor is amazing! The staff is welcoming & very professionnal. The food is tasty & of very good quality. I cannot wait to go back. I highly recommend. Special thank you to Olivia for her First Class service!

Nov 25, 2024

on Google

Harry

3.0

Very disappointed with how the quality went down lately. Used to love their pizzas but the last couple times it has been average. Not enough sauce or cheese, seems like the pizzas got smaller & the prices way higher. Needed to pay extra for the sauce when it wasn't the case before. There are better & cheaper options on the island. Will not be going back.

Oct 13, 2024

on Google

Matthew

3.0

Our group of 4 all unfortunately left disappointed. Gentile missed on attention detail & quality of product. No fault of our excellent server, seems more of a kitchen issue. To start, our mains all came out at different times. Not a few minutes apart, but 20 minutes apart. My dad finished his main before we received our pizza. When the pizzas finally came out, they were cold & not exactly as we had ordered. The waiter offered to reheat them for us, which we took her up on. As expected, the reheated pizza was overcooked & no different than leftovers. I doubt we will be back for dinner.

Sep 30, 2024

on Google

Bahar

5.0

Good restaurants stand out for their exceptional food, welcoming atmosphere, & attentive service. A great dining experience is marked by dishes that are not only delicious but also creatively presented, using fresh & high-quality ingredients. The ambiance plays a crucial role too, providing a comfortable & inviting setting that complements the meal. Friendly & knowledgeable staff can elevate the experience, making guests feel valued & well-cared for. Overall, a good restaurant is one that leaves you satisfied, eager to return, & happy to recommend to others.

Aug 20, 2024

on Google