Cafe Gentile presents an authentic taste of Italy with its expertly crafted pizzas and classic Italian dishes, perfect for any occasion. Savor the rich flavors and quality ingredients that define traditional Italian cuisine, from perfectly baked pizzas with a variety of toppings to comforting pasta creations. The inviting atmosphere provides a wonderful setting for enjoying these delightful culinary experiences. Customers can expect a memorable meal that highlights the simple yet profound pleasures of Italian cooking. It is a destination for those seeking genuine Italian flavors and a welcoming dining experience.
Cafe Gentile has become a vibrant addition to the West Island, drawing praise for its beautiful decor, welcoming atmosphere, and authentic Italian menu. Many patrons highlight the exceptional coffee and high-quality dishes, such as the pizza, pasta, and homemade desserts, as standout features of their experience. The service is frequently described as warm, attentive, and professional, with numerous staff members receiving special mentions for their dedication to guest satisfaction. While the majority of visitors leave with high praise and plans to return, some feedback points to concerns regarding noise levels, inconsistent portion sizes, and pricing. Despite these mixed remarks, the establishment remains a popular destination for families, social gatherings, and casual coffee breaks.
I finally made it to Café Gentile for brunch, & it was well worth the wait.
It was quite busy when I arrived, but I was seated at the bar, which worked perfectly since I was dining alone. Serena (I hope I'm spelling her name correctly) was working behind the bar & was absolutely lovely - warm, personable, & always smiling. I ordered the Avocado Crostini, a Gentile Spritz, & a latte. Everything was fresh & delicious, & the latte was excellent.
Since I hadn't yet tried their dinner menu, I made a reservation & returned with my husband. Once again, the restaurant was very busy, which says a lot. We were greeted warmly by the hostess & shown to our table promptly. The atmosphere is inviting & cozy, with great music that adds to the overall experience.
Our server, Bella, was attentive without being intrusive - the perfect balance. For appetizers, I had the Artichoke Crostini & my husband ordered the special (Argentine shrimp with quinoa). Both were beautifully presented & full of flavor. For mains, I chose the Grilled Branzino, which was perfectly cooked, & my husband had the Madison Square Garden pizza, which he thoroughly enjoyed.
We ended the evening with a brownie topped with marshmallow & vanilla gelato - a sweet & satisfying finish. Thank you to Serena for the thoughtful treat.
Between Serena & Bella, the service was outstanding on both visits. Café Gentile delivers not only excellent food but also a warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes you want to return.
Highly recommended for both brunch & dinner in the West Island.
The pizza is here is excellent. The ingredients are fresh, & extremely well prepared. The service is also impeccable. While on the pricey side, I would say that it is worth your money. This is my favorite pizza in the city.
We had a wonderful experience at this restaurant. Our waitress, Bella, was incredibly kind, attentive, & helpful throughout the meal - she truly made us feel welcome. We ordered pizza, & it was absolutely delicious: fresh, flavorful, & perfectly cooked. Great food & excellent service made for a really enjoyable visit. We'll definitely back !!
Jan 2, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Absolutely amazing experience! From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere felt welcoming & warm. The staff was incredibly friendly, attentive, & made us feel genuinely cared for. The service was quick but never rushed, & every recommendation they made was spot on.
The food was beyond delicious - fresh ingredients, beautifully presented, & full of flavor. You can tell there's real passion & attention to detail behind every dish. The portions were generous, & everything tasted even better than expected.
I rarely leave reviews, but this place truly deserves it. I'll definitely be coming back - highly recommend! 👏✨
I had a great experience at Café Gentile in DDO! The atmosphere is warm & welcoming, & the staff were super friendly & attentive. The food was fresh, flavourful, & beautifully presented. It's definitely a spot I'll be coming back to - highly recommend!
⭐ 1 Star
Cafe Gentile West Island - Huge Disappointment
I went to Cafe Gentile West Island with a group of seven friends, & the experience was honestly shocking. We were assigned a female waitress, & from the start, the service felt rushed. Once the food arrived, it looked nothing like the descriptions on the menu - plain, not fresh, & overall very disappointing.
Not even 45 minutes into our meal, while we were still eating, the waitress dropped the bill on the table & asked us to pay. A few minutes later she returned & told us we had five minutes to leave because they needed the table. When we asked why - & reminded her that we were still eating - she bluntly responded that they were'here to make money' & needed the table for other customers. She even told us that if we weren't happy, we should go elsewhere.
We asked to speak to a manager, & she flat-out refused.
Awful food, extremely rude staff, & zero sense of respect or customer service. Definitely not going back, & we'll be letting other locals know about this experience. What a shame for a place with so much potential.
Cafe Gentile in the West Island is absolutely fantastic. The food is incredible, fresh, flavorful, & clearly made with care. The overall dining experience is just as impressive, with warm service & a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. I genuinely can't wait to go back. Highly recommend!
