Collectively, reviews for Alfy's Pizza and Wings praise the wings for being juicy and flavorful with a wide range of sauces, including Space Jam and BBQ Jerk, and highlight the Supreme loaded fries and poutine as must try sides, while the atmosphere is described as retro and cozy and the service as friendly and attentive, sometimes going out of the way to accommodate customers. Some notes mention price or portion sizes being on the higher side, but the overall sentiment remains enthusiastic with frequent plans to return to sample more flavors.
Alfy's was recommend by a family member & I was pleasantly surprised. On Super Tuesdays small, medium & large pizza are all half prices. Especially on Tuesdays you cannot get a better price for a half descent pizza in Pierrefonds.
The nostalgic 90s décor at Alfy's is spot on & makes the whole place feel unique & amazing . The food is even better. The curry goat pizza is an absolute must-try - packed with flavour & spices that hit perfectly. The loaded fries were just as incredible. Easily one of the best spots in the area.
I am so incredibly disappointed with the owner. Very unprofessional. I would highly recommend to call before going. It's the second time I arrive & the store is not open. At least had the decency to put it on your instagram. If opening at 2 is too early for you, start opening at 6 or 7 pm & fix your hours online. Some people commute to the west for this.
This place is amazing. Such a beautiful story & an amazing owner. The food is great & was created by an amazing mind. Fresh made, unique & original you won't find anything like this! It's also beautifully decorated. Love this place 10/10 you gotta try it!
The food is good & the loaded fries are amazing -- but, strangely enough, I wish there were options for smaller sizes because they're rich. The 90's ambiance & decor really livens up the small space within the restaurant. It's like walking into a nostalgic hug... with pizza. Simpsons always on the TV, so you can quote them while you wait for your food.
Sep 25, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
We made a pit stop here on our way back to Toronto, & wow! what a delicious detour! The mutton pizza? Absolutely chef's kiss. Perfectly saucy, perfectly cheesy, & the cheese… we're still talking about it an hour later. We also tried the wings, crunchy chicken sandwich & the all-dressed fries, all were hits with the whole fam. The owners are the sweetest couple, so warm & welcoming, it felt like we were visiting friends (who happen to make amazing food). The kids loved it. We loved it. This spot just earned a permanent place on our Montreal itinerary. See you next trip!
I have heard great things about this place & finally had a chance to try it out today. First the ambiance: this place is to millenials what 50s diners are to boomers , a real blast to the past! Next, the food! We had the pizza & fries & both were great & loved by entire family. Definitely recommend!
