Overall, Alfy's Pizza and Wings gets high marks for its wide range of wing flavors, fresh wings and loaded fries, and its bold flavors with specialties like Space Jam wings and mutton pizza driving the excitement, all set in a vivid retro atmosphere with Simpsons on the TV and a friendly, helpful staff. While a few reviews mention longer wait times and some items being pricier, the overall message is that portions are generous, taste is top notch, and the vibe makes it a place worth returning to.
Their chicken wings are next level. Even if you're not into wings, they're worth a try just to get an idea. Probably my favorite item on their menu is the loaded fries. I go with a customization that makes it hotter than hell, but all their flavors are amazing. Burgers are really great, too, love the jalapeno bacon cheeseburger. Pizzas easily one of the best spots for take out in the west island, & definitely my favorite from Pierrefonds.
The person who usually works the cash is one of the chillest you'll ever speak to. Very friendly; willing to help with deciding on what to choose, & help out in general; & very relatable. His dad's also really nice. They both got lots of stories & life experience they share.
Wait time might be longer than most expect, so don't go if you're in any kind of rush. But time will fly as you chat it up with them about anything, & especially as you soak in the absolutely vivid atmosphere & ambience emanating from the place. Retro themed posters, memorabilia, merch & vibrant colors fully decorating the place. & you got Simpsons episodes playing on an overhead, & an NES-based system hooked up to a CRT for more of that nostalgia.
If there's one area of improvement, it would be if you guys could relocate nearer to me. I need that quick access.
I only found out about this when picking up my daughter from PCHS, & WOW! I will *definitely* be coming here as a regular customer. Everything honestly sounds SO good, I didn't know what to order so Ambé (I hope I spelled that right) suggested I take the Alfy's Supreme Fries with 5 Space Jam flavored wings. WHAT A COMBO!! So many have taken such GREAT pics of these already, mine wouldn't do them justice 😆 I just recently tried the JUMBO wings with some spicy garlic fries & MAN I cannot believe I didn't try this sooner! Definitely worth the extra cost if you want more of the *ridiculously good* chicken meat with loaded fries 🤩😋 Listen to Sean's recommendations & you won't regret it!
To this day, I haven't eaten juicier & more filling chicken wings. Alfy's is hands down my favorite spot in town & it's definately worth while. The chicken burger slaps & the loaded fries are also amazing. You can also ask to customize your order to your exact liking, mixing up all kinds of flavors & sauces to your heart's content.
PLEASE come & eat here if you haven't already! I always come here with friends & it is ALWAYS a treat. Sean is usually at the counter ready to serve every customer with a big smile :)
They also have The Simpsons running on repeat in the corner on their TV & it's a great vibe. You will not find a cozier 90's aesthetic anywhere else in the West Island I promise you!
We made a pit stop here on our way back to Toronto, & wow! what a delicious detour! The mutton pizza? Absolutely chef's kiss. Perfectly saucy, perfectly cheesy, & the cheese… we're still talking about it an hour later. We also tried the wings, crunchy chicken sandwich & the all-dressed fries, all were hits with the whole fam. The owners are the sweetest couple, so warm & welcoming, it felt like we were visiting friends (who happen to make amazing food). The kids loved it. We loved it. This spot just earned a permanent place on our Montreal itinerary. See you next trip!
Fried chicken burger was good. & wings was tasty. I like my wings crispy this wasnt so much but still good . The sauce buffalo & hot sauce is tangy & tasty
i had alfy's for the first time a few months ago with my boyfriend & got the large hot chicken wing poutine. it was super good. got it again recently & it seems they changed the packaging so the portion is a lot smaller... the pizza is really good, probably the best i've ever had. i think i'll just eat here once in a blue moon because of how expensive & small it is...
The ingredients they use are fresh. We love the crispy chicken burger & the French fries supreme so good. The owners are very nice as well. I would recommend this place. They have really good chicken wings too so many flavours to choose from,also the chicken itself is fresh lots of meat on the wings. Thanks alfys!
