Jack Astor's reviews describe a lively, family friendly spot with a bar and grill vibe, festive decor, and a menu that offers generous portions and a wide variety of options. The service stands out across visits, with staff described as attentive, friendly and efficient, able to handle large groups and special occasions while offering solid recommendations and quick, courteous service. The atmosphere is often praised for being welcoming and fun, with features like crayons for kids and tablecloths that invite drawing, and the Christmas decorations turning the place into a festive destination during the holidays. The food generally delivers well, with many raves about burgers, bowls, chicken dishes and crispy appetizers, plus a broad beer and cocktail selection; portions are commonly described as plentiful and prices reasonable for the quality. Occasional drawbacks include order errors, dishes that don’t stand out, and at times overcooked or underwhelming items, as well as a few notes about loud music, busy crowds, and variability by location. Overall, it comes across as a dependable, popular choice for families, friends, and celebrations, where warm service and consistent food keep guests returning despite the occasional hiccup.View restaurant profile
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Overall, reviews describe Jack Astor's as a lively, family friendly spot with a welcoming vibe, especially on game nights, where the atmosphere is festive and the terrace adds to the experience. Service is repeatedly praised as attentive, friendly, and efficient, with many servers singled out for energy and helpful menu recommendations, though a few visits note slower service or occasional lapses. The food is generally good to very good, with burgers, chicken tenders, nachos and the crab dip highlighted and portions described as generous; some dishes are seen as solid but not extraordinary and a few drinks are considered too sweet or lacking balance. Prices are viewed as high for the quality by some guests, and there are occasional comments about missing utensils or the payment process, but most patrons say they would return and would recommend it for groups, celebrations and casual meals. In short, Jack Astor's offers solid food, strong service and a lively atmosphere that keeps bringing guests back, despite some variability in value and execution.View restaurant profile
Reviews of Jack Astor's consistently highlight a lively, welcoming atmosphere with big portions and a diverse menu that keeps many guests coming back. Service is frequently praised as friendly, attentive, and efficient, with staff going the extra mile on busy nights and helping guests navigate the menu. The food is generally well received, including favorites like burgers, chicken dishes, and shared plates, and the drinks and decor are noted positively. A few reviews raise concerns about slower service, occasional tepid or greasy dishes, high prices for the quality, and noise levels that make conversation challenging. Overall, the sentiment is that Jack Astor's is a reliable go to for casual gatherings, sports events, and celebrations, with many visits described as memorable due to the atmosphere and service. The consistency varies by night and location, but the common thread is that good service and a lively vibe are central to the experience.View restaurant profile
