Best Italian Restaurants in Sherbrooke (2026) - Reviews & Menus

Parizzo

May be temporarily closed

Sherbrooke

Review Summary

Parizzo receives praise for delicious sandwiches on focaccia that feel like a mini tour of Italy along Wellington Street in Sherbrooke. Freshness and quality stand out, making it the best place in town to savor an excellent Italian sandwich, and a refreshed decor with a reading nook adds to the appeal. Reviews note that higher ratings would come if it were open later and more often, while the owner is recognized for doing incredible work. The overall impression is that Parizzo outshines fast service sandwich options and offers a standout experience that is both authentic and inviting.View restaurant profile

Da Léonardo

Open until 9 pm

(163)

Sherbrooke

Italian

Review Summary

Da Léonardo earns high marks for quality and ambience, with many reviews praising excellent food, a warm service, and a varied menu. Dishes such as fresh pasta, risotto, veal escalope parmigiana, lasagna, and pizza are highlighted, and the wine list is regularly complimented; the restaurant is described as lively and inviting with a large terrace, a good fit for family or group dining. Service quality is praised in many visits, but several reviews note slow pacing and long waits between courses, and in some cases guests were asked to leave after finishing their meals. Portions are frequently generous, appreciated for value by some while others worry about waste and pricing mismatches. When the kitchen and service align, the experience is described as excellent with authentic Italian flavors, but inconsistent experiences lead some to hesitate about returning. Overall, Da Léonardo stands out as a strong Italian option in the area, offering great food and a convivial atmosphere with plans to return depending on timing and crowd levels.View restaurant profile

Reserve

Sballo

Italian BYOW restaurant with exposed-brick walls & a bring-your-own-wine policy.

Opens Today at 5 pm

(5)

Sherbrooke

Italian Pasta

Review Summary

At Sballo, guests praise sublime gnocchi, impeccable service, and ultra delicious and authentic Italian food, set in an elegant, refined atmosphere. It is described as a preferred place to dine in Sherbrooke, and many consider it the best dining experience in the city.View restaurant profile

Order

Pizzicato

Opens Today at 4 pm

(2427)

Sherbrooke

Pizza Pasta Italian Salads

Review Summary

Reviews describe Pizzicato as a lively Italian spot where pizza and pasta shine, with gnocchi, ravioli, and fresh pasta earning frequent praise for flavor, generous portions, and good value. The bring your own wine option and the ability to take home products are noted as pluses, and the ambiance is described as warm and welcoming with friendly, efficient service by many staff. Some visits mention slower service during peak times and a bit of ambient noise, while a few dishes are noted as smaller in portion or less consistent in texture. On the flip side, many diners highlight spectacular pizza crusts, excellent entrees, and a varied menu that makes it a reliable go-to for celebrations or meals before or after cinema, often with people planning to return. Overall, Pizzicato is viewed as an institution in the area and a dependable choice with strong flavors, solid value, and a convivial atmosphere.View restaurant profile

Pizzéria NO.900

Open until 9 pm

(102)

Sherbrooke

Pizza Pizzeria Italian Gluten-free Options

Mentioned in: Exploring Quebec City's Pizzerias: Our Recommendations 19 Must-Try Food Trucks in Montreal for a True Street Food Experience View More

Review Summary

Pizzéria NO.900 draws mixed impressions, with many praising fresh ingredients, light not greasy pizzas, and quick cooking, and some noting the option to buy ingredients to make your own at home. Several reviews mention friendly service for some and inattentiveness for others, and a few note language barriers. The pizzas are described as authentic with a thin crust and bright toppings, though a couple of pies are said to lack flavor or be a bit pricey. Desserts are highlighted, including a house chocolate hazelnut pizza and cannoli, and there are gluten free rice dough options. The atmosphere is generally pleasant with good ambiance, but music or energy can feel off to some. Overall, Pizzéria NO.900 is considered a solid choice with authentic taste and fair value, and many would return, while noting areas for improvement in service consistency and pricing.View restaurant profile

Pacini

Open until 10 pm

(436)

Sherbrooke

Italian Grill Pasta Pizza Gluten-free Options

Review Summary

Reviews for Pacini present a mixed picture: the food is often described as fresh and well prepared with standout items like a shrimp risotto and a pleasant lemony note, and a bread bar is frequently noted as a positive touch, but desserts and certain pasta dishes can disappoint, with tiramisu not meeting expectations and pasta portions sometimes small or bland. Service is described as warm and professional when attentive, yet slow or inconsistent at times, and the restaurant can feel crowded and noisy, affecting the dining experience. Some guests report good value and quick service for lunch, while others find portions overpriced or the overall experience not worth the cost, and a few issues such as plates served burnt or incorrect orders are mentioned. Overall Pacini seems to deliver high quality ingredients and thoughtful preparation on a good day, but the overall experience varies across visits.View restaurant profile

Le Ranch du Spaghetti

Open until 9:30 pm

(131)

Sherbrooke

Pasta Pizza Grill Italian

Review Summary

Patrons describe Le Ranch du Spaghetti as a lively spot with a warm family friendly vibe and generous portions. The food is frequently praised as delicious with pasta dishes lasagna and veal parmesan among the standouts and a notable bread bar with a variety of spreads. Gluten free spaghetti is available and often well received. Service is described as excellent and attentive at times though some visits note slower pace during busy periods and occasional lapses. Several reviews highlight value for money although a few mention higher prices and occasional billing or service missteps. The ambiance is repeatedly described as cozy and welcoming making it a good option for casual meals with family or friends. Some guests mention the bread bar as a standout feature while others point to issues like small portions for the price or problems with the bill. Overall the consensus is that the restaurant delivers solid Italian comfort with generous portions and a lively atmosphere albeit with some inconsistencies in service and value depending on the visit.View restaurant profile

Order

Di Me Tutto Pizzeria

Open until 11 pm

(62)

Sherbrooke

Pizza Italian

Review Summary

Di Me Tutto Pizzeria garners mostly glowing reviews for a true Italian style pizza with a light, crispy crust and fresh, high quality ingredients, and a homemade dough that many readers call standout, with favorites like chicken and pesto and a range of pizzas and calzones that keep coming up as delicious; the atmosphere and service are repeatedly described as warm and welcoming, the staff patient and friendly, and the overall experience is often praised as setting the place apart, with many reviewers noting good value. Delivery feedback is mixed, including a few reports of a burnt crust on delivery or order mixups and at least one instance of receiving Pepsi Zero Sugar instead of Pepsi, but this does not overshadow the general sentiment of satisfaction with the food. Taken together, the reviews position this pizzeria as a top local choice, celebrated for flavorful pizza, generous toppings, a hospitable vibe, and a clean, well kept setting.View restaurant profile

Order

DaToni Pronto

Open until 8 pm

(65)

Sherbrooke

Pasta Pizza Italian

Review Summary

DaToni Pronto is described as a quiet, welcoming spot in Sherbrooke where diners praise generous portions, fast service, and a strong lineup of pizzas and pastas, with many noting the overall high quality and consistent flavors along with a family friendly ambiance and good value; some reviews mention a few inconsistencies, such as a salmon pasta texture that felt odd and a carbonara that seemed to lack enough garnish or flavor, and one note of a pizza that was too salty and dry; several customers also appreciate menu variety including vegetarian options, the ability to buy their frozen lasagna, and the idea of combo meals, while others would like the space to be a bit larger with more comfortable seating; multiple comments place it as a standout in Sherbrooke and say they would come back on future visits.View restaurant profile