Best Italian Restaurants in Magog (2026) - Reviews & Menus

Magog

Pizza Pizzeria Italian Gluten-free Options

Mentioned in: Exploring Quebec City's Pizzerias: Our Recommendations

Review Summary

Reviews of Pizzéria NO.900 consistently praise a warm, modern yet cozy atmosphere and a crowd-pleasing menu that includes gluten-free and vegan options as well as carnivore friendly choices, with the pizzas delivering a thin, chewy crust that many describe as authentic Neapolitan and topped with fresh ingredients. Service is repeatedly lauded for being friendly, accommodating and attentive, with the owners often on site adding to the welcoming vibe, and the overall dining experience often described as calm and relaxed even during peak times. The offering spans appetizers, pizza and cocktails, and several comments note good value, especially the lunch special that includes a salad, while the wine list is highlighted as a nice bonus. Some reviews mention standout pizzas such as Margherita and regional styles like Charlevoix, and others reference the versatility of the menu and the quality of the ingredients. A minority report a few missteps during busy periods, such as a beer no longer on tap or occasional dishes arriving dirty, but the consensus remains highly favorable and positions Pizzéria NO.900 as a top Magog choice for pizza lovers.View restaurant profile

La Piazzetta

Open until 9 pm

(711)

Magog

Pizza Italian Salads Bistro Mediterranean Pasta

Mentioned in: Exploring Quebec City's Pizzerias: Our Recommendations

Review Summary

La Piazzetta earns praise for high quality food and a warm, welcoming atmosphere, with a menu that includes vegetarian and vegan options and an English version for non French speakers; pizza is frequently highlighted as a standout and many entrees are described as well prepared and tasty. Service is often attentive and friendly, but several reviews note slow or uneven service during busy times and occasional delays between courses. Some dishes fall short, such as pasta that is underseasoned or overcooked and a few pizzas with thin crust or uneven toppings, yet others emphasize good value and generous lunch specials. The decor is described as elegant without being stuffy and the ambiance can feel cozy or romantic, contributing to a pleasant dining experience. The location on the main street with parking nearby is convenient, and many readers say they would return.View restaurant profile

Benito Bistro Italien (Chez Benito)

Open until 10 pm

(725)

Magog

Italian Bistro Pasta

Review Summary

Benito Bistro Italien (Chez Benito) is described as a cozy, intimate Italian restaurant with a warm ambience and a charming waterside terrace, where the food is repeatedly praised for flavor and generous portions. Dishes such as lemon veal scaloppine, ravioli, seafood pasta, lasagna with fresh pasta, mushroom and truffle oil pizza, and tiramisu are frequently highlighted as highlights, and service is often noted as friendly, professional, and attentive, helping create many memorable evenings. Some reviewers report inconsistencies, including variable meat quality for the lemon veal, gnocchi that were pan fried and burnt, long waits during peak times, and occasional value concerns when portions are small for the price or certain items fall short of expectations. Overall, the reviews point to a strong, engaging Italian dining experience with a welcoming atmosphere, and many guests say they would return.View restaurant profile

Reserve

Buon Gusto

Opens Tomorrow at 10 am

(20)

Magog

Italian Sandwiches

Review Summary

Buon Gusto in Magog comes across as a top destination for fine Italian delicatessen and homemade prepared dishes, with seafood lasagna repeatedly highlighted and the Italian imported products described as remarkable. The place is described as a local treasure with friendly, attentive service and a warm welcome. Dishes such as lasagna with meat and mushrooms are called divine, the pizza tastes like Italy, and tiramisu is often praised as among the best. A seafood casserole is noted as absolutely delicious, while the olives receive high praise. The overall experience is framed as a home restaurant that customers are encouraged to support, and regulars call it the best caterer in Magog. Desserts and cakes receive affectionate mentions, and many reviewers say they would return for events, appreciating high quality ingredients and consistent care throughout the menu, along with festive goodwill.View restaurant profile

Alessa Trattoria

Open until 10 pm

(502)

Magog

Italian Pizza

Mentioned in: On the Hunt for Montreal's Best Cannoli

Review Summary

Overall, reviews of Alessa Trattoria highlight authentic Italian cooking with fresh, house-made sauces and a wide menu of pastas, pizzas, antipasti, and desserts that many guests describe as flavorful and well prepared, with several calling the experience the best Italian meal in the area and noting the wine and cocktail selections as a plus; the atmosphere is repeatedly praised as warm, chic, and lively, with some guests enjoying the terrace while others note that the space can be noisy and tables feel crowded; service is often described as attentive, friendly, and professional, though a few visits mention occasional missteps or moments of brusqueness and one or two concerns about water service or temperature; value is generally considered good for the quality, though a handful of reviews feel portions or prices can be high, and a couple of comments emphasize the importance of reservations and variability in portion size; despite occasional critiques, the consensus is that Alessa Trattoria offers a memorable, dependable Italian dining experience that brings locals and visitors back for repeat visits.View restaurant profile

Order

Steforno La Fabrique

Open until 9 pm

(241)

Magog

Pizza Charcuterie Italian

Review Summary

Steforno La Fabrique is widely praised for pizza with a crisp crust and fresh toppings, and for friendly, efficient service that many diners describe as attentive. The atmosphere is convivial with large communal tables that foster conversation, though some find it noisy and a bit chilly inside. While a few experiences note longer waits or occasional timing or pricing hiccups, most reviews emphasize memorable meals, welcoming staff, and a sense of authentic Italian dining; the restaurant is regarded as a must visit in the area, with several mentions of special events going smoothly thanks to a dedicated team, and overall it remains a top choice for pizza and Italian cuisine despite a few caveats about pacing and comfort.View restaurant profile