Gibeau Orange Julep is described as a Montreal icon and a must-visit for its giant orange building and signature frothy orange drink. The juice is repeatedly praised for being refreshing and uniquely creamy, though several reviews note that it can be very sweet and sometimes asks for balancing with ice cream or a larger amount of juice. Food offerings receive mixed signals, with poutine praised for richness and comfort by some and criticized as overpriced or mediocre by others, while hot dogs and fries are described as hit or miss. The atmosphere is celebrated for nostalgia and the open-air parking lot, but seating is limited and the place can feel touristy or crowded, especially during peak times. Overall, the orange juice remains the highlight, driving repeat visits even when some menu items disappoint and the value is questioned.View restaurant profile