Slice + Soda is widely praised for giant, affordable slices with a thin, crispy crust and fresh toppings that give a New York style feel in a compact, welcoming space. Reviewers note that the slices are big, fast to serve, and often satisfying as a quick bite, with classic and creative toppings like pepperoni, Margherita, veggie, carnivore, prosciutto, and a Caesar salad pairing complementing the pizza. The crust is described as airy yet crisp with a balanced sauce, and some add olive oil or chili flakes for extra kick. The open kitchen and casual, cozy ambiance, sometimes with a communal table, contribute to a neighborhood vibe that many enjoy, while seating can be limited and lines can get long on busy nights. Service is usually friendly and efficient, though a few visits mention variability in product quality or dish availability, such as reduced toppings on a later visit. Diners frequently note the value, with large slices for a reasonable price, and some call it the best pizza in Montreal or a must try, particularly for a quick meal in Old Montreal. Overall, Slice + Soda comes across as a reliable go to for a tasty, satisfyingly sized slice that pairs well with sodas and a casual, lively atmosphere.
Really wanted to like the pizza, as the dude at the register was friendly, & a dug the ambiance. However, the pizza wasn't the greatest. Idk if it's the NYer I am, but the cheese didn't melt together, which was weird, & you couldn't hold the slice up without it collapsing.
Was in the old port after a nice afternoon. It was getting late & me & my wife had a craving for a slice of pizza for takeout, it was approaching 21h40...wasn't sure if we would fine a place on our walk...but let me tell you we found THE best place for pizza, big generous slice excellent service did not wait that long even with a long waiting line. Highly recommend this place. Keep up the good work.
Pizza was good but it's not the best I've tried. I like the price (I spent about 11$ for pizza & coke) & design of this place. So atmospheric & nice. This is the coolest pizzeria in Montreal
Aug 29, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Gargantuesque pizza a croute mince, le double de la superficie de ma main! Texture & toppings were great. The slice was fairly priced & the staff was sweet.
Nous avons visité plusieurs & recommencerons l'expérience n'importe quand.
Great pizza! Well priced, the soda selection excellent as well. I'm a big Beastie Boys fan so, I love the logo. Great ambiance, really cool pictures all around the place. 😁
Très bonne pizza (absolument immense !!) dans un restaurant avec une belle ambiance, le tout servi gentiment & amicalement. & le prix était très bon. Au top !
