Overall, Slice + Soda earns high marks for giant New York style slices, generous toppings, and a lively, casual vibe. Reviewers repeatedly describe the crust as airy and crisp with a chewy interior, and praise toppings from pepperoni and carnivore to Margherita and veggie for freshness and abundance. The pies are said to be surprisingly affordable for their size, with fast, friendly service and a straightforward, quick bite ideal for lunch or a casual late night stop. The open kitchen and cozy, compact atmosphere add to the charm, and the soda lineup pairs well with the pizza. While a few visits mention occasional dips in quantity or consistency, the overall impression is that Slice + Soda delivers big slices, solid flavor, and dependable value, making it a go-to option in Old Montreal.
Recently moved here from the New York City metropolitan area, & can say that they delivered great slice, & the service is excellent. If you like New York style pizza, this place delivers & for a great price.
On my first trip to Montreal, I ended up walking about 12.5 kilometers through the city, exploring & taking photos-so by the time I spotted Slice + Soda, I had definitely worked up an appetite. I originally wandered in thinking they served poutine (because, let's be real, poutine & pizza sounds like a dream combo), but once I realized they didn't, I stuck around anyway. The cool vibe inside & the sight of a grinning customer walking out with three oversized boxes of pizza was all the convincing I needed.
The staff were friendly, bilingual, & super efficient. Service was fast, & I was able to grab a spot just in time before a line started forming. Seating is very limited-just a few stools lining the wall & one communal table that could fit maybe 4-6 people, so timing your visit definitely helps.
The interior is visually fun, with movie stills of iconic characters eating pizza plastered along the walls, & the whole place has this stylish, street-food-meets-film-nerd charm. I ordered a pepperoni slice that was literally bigger than my head, a soda, & some waffle-style fries that were crispy, seasoned, & way better than I expected.
There was a ton of construction outside, so the pedestrian traffic was pretty filtered & narrow-otherwise I imagine the place would've been absolutely packed.
Sure, pizza might not be top of the list for most tourists visiting Montreal, but if you're after a quick, cheap, & genuinely tasty lunch, Slice + Soda checks all the boxes. I'd absolutely go back.
Apr 12, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Affordable & super-tasty NY-style pizza. They have some unique options & their soda choices are also really fun The ambiance inside is great too if you want to eat there - roomy & lowkey
If you are walking around the area is a good place to grab & go. Pizza is good but not the best. The staff is friendly & the place has a few high seats & 8 chairs on a big square table. They open late & you can swing by & eat quickly. Brooklyn style pizza, sodas. Nice decoration.
My go to pizzeria every time i visit Montreal . Most authentic brooklyn style pizza or italian style- i wouldnt know. But the quality, the freshness, the cheesyness , everything is so on point. 10/10
Nice little pizza place that was around the area that I was staying in so I thought I would give it a try. Got the trio combo which gives you a slice of pizza, a drink & fries which was a fairly good deal at $14 before tax. I got the prosciutto pizza slice with Bae soda. The pizza slice was really large which was nice to see. The soda also tasted great, had a fruity taste which paired well with the carbonated water for that fizz. The fries were waffle style with a spicy kick to it. Now on to the main course; after taking a bite of the slice, I have to say, it was one of the best pizza slices I've ever had in my life. The undercarriage was firm, nice amount of ingredients & incredible tasting tomato sauce. The prosciutto also tasted very great & combined all those flavours together. Incredible pizza with good portion sizes & a flavourful soda to top it off. Definitely a must try if you are in the area.
Oct 28, 2024
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Un vrai coup de coeur ! Slice & Soda propose des pizzas new-yorkaises incroyables, des sodas créatifs & des cookies au top, le tout dans un décor vintage stylé. L'atmosphère est branchée, le service rapide & amical. Attention alerte pépite :)
We love New York style pizza, & this is some of the best we have ever tasted! Huge slices, somewhat of a sweet sauce & a great crust made for the perfect combination! Cesar salad was super tasty as well. Highly recommend!
Wow!! That pizza taste amazing, New York style pizza at its best! & the portions are incredibly generous. My kids & I also tried their homemade sodas, the mixes are delicious. We can't wait to go back!
