Pizzeria Sofia elevates the art of traditional pizza through a commitment to high quality ingredients and authentic Italian techniques. The kitchen focuses on hand stretched dough that achieves a distinctively crisp yet airy crust, topped with artisanal cheeses and vibrant, vine ripened tomato sauces. Each pie reflects a mastery of heat and timing, utilizing a specialized oven to deliver perfectly charred edges and melted, flavorful profiles. Beyond the signature pizzas, the menu features a curated selection of Italian staples crafted with technical precision and consistent execution. The dining room offers an uncomplicated aesthetic that centers the culinary experience on the plate. Patrons encounter a reliable standard of preparation where every element serves a distinct purpose in the overall composition of the dish.
Pizzeria Sofia is frequently praised for its high-quality Italian cuisine, particularly its wood-fired pizzas, fresh pasta, and generous portions, which many diners consider among the best in the city. While many guests enjoy the modern, trendy atmosphere and attentive service from staff, others find the environment overly noisy, making conversation difficult. Opinions on pricing are mixed, with some diners feeling the food justifies the cost, while others consider it quite expensive and express frustration over the policy of charging for water. Although some patrons report inconsistencies in service speed and occasional issues with food temperature or specific menu items, the overall sentiment highlights a stylish restaurant well-suited for special occasions or social gatherings.
We've visited this location a few times before, as well as their Rosemère location, & the restaurant always impresses with its beautiful, modern decor.
We were seated in a central booth in a relatively calm dining room. As the evening progressed, the atmosphere became much more energetic.
To her credit, our waitress, Emanuelle, stepped in & brought the noise level back down to something manageable. Her professionalism made a real difference.
Now, the food-this is where Sofia truly shines.
With no gluten-free pizza dough available that evening, I opted for the rigatoni cacio e pepe, topped with black truffle paste (normally served with gnocchi). The gluten-free pasta held up beautifully, & the dish was rich, creamy, & deeply flavorful, with that earthy truffle note adding a refined touch.
My wife ordered the cavatelli with San Marzano tomato sauce & basil-simple, classic, & very well executed. Portions across the board were generous.
To start, I had a Caesar salad (sans croûtons)-fresh, crisp, & again, very generous. My wife chose the fritto misto, a beautifully presented plate of fried calamari & shrimp served with a spicy mayonnaise.
Dessert was a standout: fondant al cioccolato, served with Nutella cream, caramelized pears, vanilla gelato, & a hazelnut-chocolate tuile. Decadent, well-balanced, & absolutely worth saving room for.
For wine, a glass of Sauvignon Blanc paired nicely on her side, while I went with a bold Chianti-both solid choices.
Final take: The kitchen delivers consistently excellent food with generous portions & thoughtful execution. Service, especially from Emanuelle, was attentive & solution-oriented. The only drawback was the noise level, which at times detracted from the overall experience.
Would we return? Yes-for the food & service. Hopefully next time, with a slightly quieter soundtrack.
If you read my other reviews , I never complain. I love food & I'm not picky. But this place … the food was overly salty. & we spoke up about it to the waitress which was wonderful by the way, & she told us we were the 4th table to have voiced that.
The manager came in hot , with an annoyed attitude , it was already 10pm when we received our food ….. (we had a reservation a 8pm, got seated at 8:22pm, & received our food at 10pm) he's like but why didn't you tell us that your food was salty. BRO I WAS STARVING & I genuinely thought it was like me being crazy or maybe the Parmegiano . I don't know . We didn't finish our plates, the pizza was barely touched. Even a waiter tried our food & said it was way too salty.
So the manger was like well tell me what do you want we can make it but it was already 10:10pm at the time.
So they deducted my pasta plate & the pizza. But it was just the arrogance of the manager. How come I had to argue with him that the food was disgusting. Like you literally have 4 other tables who also have complained .
The appetizers were fine but seriously what a mediocre even lower than average food.
Will never set foot again.
Apr 27, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
I am giving two stars only because of the service; the waiters were very kind. However, to be asked if you want water & then being charged 5.50$ is crazy & a little deceiving. The pasta was a bit cold & the portion was very small. The food itself is okay but my expectations were higher given it is a pretty pricey restaurent, overall kind of disappointing.
The pasta was absolutely delicious-fresh, flavorful, & perfectly cooked. However, the prices are way too high for what you get. On top of that, charging for water is just ridiculous. It's a basic expectation in a restaurant, not an extra luxury. The service was also a bit overwhelming-there were too many waiters constantly coming by, which felt more distracting than helpful. Overall, good food, but not worth the price.
We went on a Tuesday & the place was empty but the staff was nice & the food was good yet a bit pricey. My friends went on a Wednesday right after lunch time & the place was closed. They specialize in wood oven pizza & pasta. It's also a supper club type spot where some people go for drinks on weekends mostly.
Pizza & Pasta are amazing. However, the service was Awful!! With a reservation, we waited 15 minutes at the door to get seated. Don't forget to bring water bottles since they charge for water & don't serve tap water!
