One Punch Mickey's is viewed as a welcoming spot with great service, friendly staff, and a menu that shines with unique drinks. Reviews note that bartenders chat easily, sometimes devising drinks not on the menu to suit the moment, and that the atmosphere is a mix of cozy pub and lively sports bar ideal for beers and watching games. The Irish theme comes through in decor and vibes, with many praising the top notch ambiance and the option of darts, while drink highlights include house cocktails and crowd favorites like the "Irish trashcan," alongside solid beer options and the occasional critique that Guinness prices can be high. The venue can get busy on peak nights, yet guests describe it as fun and welcoming, with attentive service and a social, laid back feel that makes it easy to return. Overall, One Punch Mickey's emerges as a favorite neighborhood pub known for its character, reliable service, and a memorable, easygoing experience that draws regulars back.
I waited about 5 minutes for a server to take our order, but no one came. I ended up going to the bar myself, where I had to wait another 5 minutes before being served.
I ordered two beers, & when it was time to pay, the tip options on the terminal were 18%, 20%, & 25%, which is above what I would consider standard. I chose not to leave a tip since I essentially had to do everything myself & still waited quite a while.
Someone who appeared to be the manager approached me & asked why I had not left a tip. I explained the situation, & they responded,'The bartenders here do not get a salary, so their income comes from tips.'
That is, of course, illegal. It is not my responsibility to compensate for that, especially when the service was poor. Trying to make a customer feel guilty on top of that is completely inappropriate.
Definitely not planning to come back.
Mar 21, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
This is the perfect dive bar. Actually we'll priced alcohol, a very fun & vibrant ambience, good music, & altogether a very chill relaxed vibe. Extra points for the very interesting decor & the very welcoming staff.
Great service, friendly staff & unique drinks.
Went to One Punch Mickey's for some drinks last night & to catch up with an old friend & I really enjoyed my time there. Bartender made good conversation, offered to make us a unique & fun drink that wasn't on the menu when my friend was hesitating, & we had a good time overall.
I would thoroughly suggest the Irish trashcan drink if you enjoy sweet drinks, it was absolutely delicious.
Parfait pour une virée entre amis ou pour venir se siffler une bière pendant que les gamins font la sieste. Une ambiance au top. Un décors au top. Un staff au top. Amusez-vous bien & n'oubliez pas de tipper 25% car ils le valent !
What a really great bar! Got served by William & the service & customer service was amazing.
One of the best Irish car bombs ive had. They aren't cheap on the Guinness. I love they're house cocktails & the theme & atmosphere is on point. Really friendly open & easy,to just lay back & grab one to many.
I like there bloody mockey & how they come with a complementary pepperoni & goes so well with the drink. Im coming back when im not driving & letting lose!
