Bona Fide is a tiny neighborhood Italian spot that delivers a big wow with warm hospitality, an intimate setting, and a wine program. Diners consistently praise the beef tartare as a standout and the overall freshness of the small plates, with handmade pastas and dishes like duck ragu and squash with brown butter standing out. The atmosphere is cozy yet refined, and service is frequently described as attentive and personal. The wine list and thoughtful pairings receive frequent applause. While the cooking is described as precise and elevated without being fussy, a few notes mention richer mains, heavier sauces, or higher prices for wine by the glass. Overall this spot is seen as one of Montreal's top Italian restaurants and a go to for a comforting, memorable meal.
The portions were generous without being overwhelming, which made the whole meal feel well-balanced & worth it. On top of that, the service was excellent - attentive, friendly, & efficient without being overbearing.
Overall, Bona Fide delivered on all fronts: great food, solid portions, & top-notch service. I'll definitely be coming back.
Best italian food I've ever had in North America period. Even compared to Italy it's a tough battle. We went to Sicily for our honeymoon for 10 days & we thought the pasta is better at Bona Fide. Beyond the unbelievable food, the service is just fantastic & the vibe is really nice. One of our absolute favorite restaurants in Montreal.
Excellent service à la clientèle, excellente nourriture, délicieux de L'entrée au dessert, un vrai délice culinaire, mes papilles gustatives en redemandent! Merci! Pour nos 11 ans de mariage, la place était parfaite! Chaleureuse, intime, ambiance parfaite! Merci! Milles fois merci!
Nice small restaurant in the neighbourhood. The staff is nice & welcoming. The appetizers were good, the salad was refreshing. The pasta was average, lacked flavour. Overall great restaurant.
Je suis allée au restaurant pour la première fois le 8 janvier à 18 h & j'ai reçu un excellent service de la part des deux serveurs.
Malheureusement, je n'ai pas pris leurs noms. Cela faisait longtemps que je n'étais pas allé dans un restaurant où l'on ne ressentait pas l'effet « après-Covid » sur le service à la clientèle.
J'ai été accueilli chaleureusement. Tous les plats étaient excellents & goûteux, & esthétiquement, c'était un véritable plaisir pour les yeux.
J'ai pris le tartare de boeuf en entrée, l'un des meilleurs tartares que j'ai mangés. Par la suite, le morceau espagnol était excellent, & les pâtes caramel étaient bonnes aussi.
J'y retournerai, c'est certain !!
Jan 14, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Best. Restaurant. In. Montreal… according to my chef girlfriend & server self (industry insight ought to count surely?!). The food is masterful, every dish is a technical masterpiece combining the all-too-rare technical precision with a well thought out & intentioned dish. WOW! As for the service, to sum it in a word: impeccable, with all the quintessentially elegant/familiar Montreal charm, a beverage program & wine list to pair perfectly with any meal. I mean come on.. it's not even fair. GOAT 🐐
The food, service (especially the attentive owner), wine list & overall atmosphere are all excellent. I really cannot recommend Bona Fide enough. I'm already planning my next visit.
Super resto de quartier ! L'endroit est petit, & c'est justement ce qui fait tout son charme. On ne croirait pas être sur St-Laurent, au coin de Crémazie.
La veille de mon événement, un autre restaurant a annulé ma réservation à cause d'une erreur de leur part. En appelant au Bona Fide, le patron a réussi à arranger quelque chose pour nous accueillir.
Le service était chaleureux & nous avons beaucoup apprécié la nourriture & le vin. Ce fut une soirée réellement agréable, une très belle découverte.
Merci au patron, Luigi, sympathique & très avenant.
Sans hésitation un des meilleurs restaurants italiens de Montréal. Le tartare de boeuf & les pâtes fraîches sont exceptionnelles. Une belle carte des vins & surtout un service ultra sympathique.
Duck ragu so good we got it twice, & since we had to wait 30 min for our table our server gave us the squash appetizer for free & it was DELICIOUS. Everything was amazing, super cozy restaurant, server was very sweet & accommodating
Nov 29, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
What a fantastic dinner we had here. The wine suggestion was excellent, the tartare was tangy, not too heavy, & just so enjoyable to eat. The squash/brown butter pasta dish was the star of the show. Excellent service. Beautiful atmosphere. We loved the window seat so much, it's definitely the best table. Thank you!!
Bona Fide is some of the best Italian I've had in Montreal! Loved every dish I had, including a delicious tartare with caciocavello, delicata squash, sage agnolotti & duck ragu. They had a mackerel ratatouille special which tasted very homey, but also had expertly cooked crispy skin. Would be well worth another visit to taste other pasta dishes!
Thank you random Reddit guy for the recommendation!
