Benedetta offers a warm, elegant setting in the Old Port with a charming courtyard and a welcoming atmosphere, pairing friendly, attentive service with consistently high quality Italian inspired cuisine. The food receives frequent praise for freshness, balanced flavors, and careful presentation across pizzas, pastas, paninis and brunch dishes, and cocktails and espresso are often highlighted as excellent. The vibe is cozy yet refined, making it popular for dates, casual dinners, or gatherings, with the courtyard and a downstairs speakeasy adding to the appeal. Occasional notes mention long waits during peak times, and a few dishes are described as lacking depth or being overpriced, along with practical hints like parking considerations. Overall Benedetta comes across as a standout Old Port spot with reliable food, a memorable atmosphere, and hospitality that encourages a return visit.
I went to Benedetta on February 14th for Valentine's Day. It's a new restaurant that opened in early December, & unfortunately, that inexperience shows.
The 5-course menu was nicely presented visually, but that's about where the praise ends. The first three courses were average at best. Honestly, you could make the same dishes at home without much effort. Nothing memorable, nothing refined enough to justify a tasting menu.
The main course was decent on my end, but my partner's bavette steak was completely rubbery. I took one bite & had to spit it out immediately because it was impossible to chew. For a restaurant positioning itself as upscale, serving meat like that is unacceptable.
The dessert tasted no better than a basic Betty Crocker brownie you could make at home. No finesse, no depth, no'wow' factor.
As for the drinks, they were just okay. The lychee martini was borderline, & that's a cocktail that's pretty hard to mess up. At one point I sent a drink back after only 2-3 sips because it simply wasn't good, & it still showed up on the final bill.
The service was disappointing from start to finish. The staff seemed stressed & disorganized. About 5-10 minutes after we sat down - before we even had time to properly look at the menu - the server was already rolling his eyes. He would drop off the plates & walk away immediately, not even taking the time to explain the dish. There was little to no attention throughout the meal, & we were rarely asked if everything was okay.
All of this would have been easier to overlook if the price reflected the experience. But $340 including tax & tip for two people is excessive for what we received. At that price point, you can easily get a far better meal elsewhere.
Very disappointing for what was supposed to be a special evening.
Très mauvaise expérience à ce restaurant, c'est malheureux car il y a beaucoup de potentiel mais le service est mauvais & la nourriture est de piètre qualité. Je déconseille fortement ce restaurant le décor est est pas au goût du jour & ils veulent seulement votre argent.
Feb 14, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Amazing new restaurant in the heart of old port. Food was exquisite, you can tell they source high quality products & the chef is super skilled. The service was also super good compared to other places in Montreal. The place is charming, minimally decorated that lets the bones of the building speak for themselves. Good place to hang out with friends or even for a date. There's a speakeasy club downstairs with as much charm!
Jan 1, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
We were a group of 14 people, & had a great time. Service was quick & friendly. We enjoyed the cocktails & the shots. We enjoyed the place & will go back soon.
Dec 9, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Benedetta was amazing! The atmosphere is warm & stylish, the service is professional & friendly, & the food is outstanding. The pasta is perfectly made, the flavors are rich & well-balanced, & every dish feels carefully crafted. You can tell the team knows what they're doing. This place is going to become a staple in the city. Highly recommend.
Love the lounge atmosphere with a lovely European accent, where the new integrates quite well with the old. Excellent food, outstanding service too ! I highly recommend it & will be coming back for sure !
We make it a point to always come by & dine at Benedetta whenever we are in Montreal. The food is good but the service is where things shine. Anne & her team go above & beyond to take care of all your needs to ensure that your experience is fun, courteous, & accommodated. We always have great laughs & smiles with that team.
I've been coming here for coffee every morning but recently discovered they had a brunch on the weekends! The chicken & waffles is phenomenal here. So are the pancakes. Super fluffy & a generous serving. Highly recommend. Coffee is good too
J'ai adoré mon expérience au Benedetta! Le restaurant a un charme unique avec sa superbe cour intérieure & son ambiance chaleureuse. Le service était impeccable : rapide, attentionné & toujours souriant.
