Benedetta offers a warm, elegant setting in the Old Port with a charming courtyard and a welcoming atmosphere, pairing friendly, attentive service with consistently high quality Italian inspired cuisine. The food receives frequent praise for freshness, balanced flavors, and careful presentation across pizzas, pastas, paninis and brunch dishes, and cocktails and espresso are often highlighted as excellent. The vibe is cozy yet refined, making it popular for dates, casual dinners, or gatherings, with the courtyard and a downstairs speakeasy adding to the appeal. Occasional notes mention long waits during peak times, and a few dishes are described as lacking depth or being overpriced, along with practical hints like parking considerations. Overall Benedetta comes across as a standout Old Port spot with reliable food, a memorable atmosphere, and hospitality that encourages a return visit.
Worst experience at a restaurant. It took around 20 minutes to get water AFTER being seated, another 10-15 for our drinks & when we ordered food, we waited an hour for two cold soups & none of the sandwiches ordered. We didn't get checked on by our waiter once. It's a beautiful ambience inside & we were really excited to have lunch there but the service did not meet the expectations. I don't recommend it until they figure out their stuff. Disappointed.
I went to Benedetta on February 14th for Valentine's Day. It's a new restaurant that opened in early December, & unfortunately, that inexperience shows.
The 5-course menu was nicely presented visually, but that's about where the praise ends. The first three courses were average at best. Honestly, you could make the same dishes at home without much effort. Nothing memorable, nothing refined enough to justify a tasting menu.
The main course was decent on my end, but my partner's bavette steak was completely rubbery. I took one bite & had to spit it out immediately because it was impossible to chew. For a restaurant positioning itself as upscale, serving meat like that is unacceptable.
The dessert tasted no better than a basic Betty Crocker brownie you could make at home. No finesse, no depth, no'wow' factor.
As for the drinks, they were just okay. The lychee martini was borderline, & that's a cocktail that's pretty hard to mess up. At one point I sent a drink back after only 2-3 sips because it simply wasn't good, & it still showed up on the final bill.
The service was disappointing from start to finish. The staff seemed stressed & disorganized. About 5-10 minutes after we sat down - before we even had time to properly look at the menu - the server was already rolling his eyes. He would drop off the plates & walk away immediately, not even taking the time to explain the dish. There was little to no attention throughout the meal, & we were rarely asked if everything was okay.
All of this would have been easier to overlook if the price reflected the experience. But $340 including tax & tip for two people is excessive for what we received. At that price point, you can easily get a far better meal elsewhere.
Very disappointing for what was supposed to be a special evening.
Feb 15, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Benedetta is such a gem in the Vieux-Port! The atmosphere is warm & inviting, the service is friendly, & you can really taste the freshness in every dish. Their cocktails are creative & delicious, & the food has that perfect mix of comfort & elegance. A must-visit whether you're out for brunch, dinner, or just a drink in the Old Port.
Benedetta is one of the most impressive spots in the city. Whether you're coming for brunch, drinks, or just a good time, everything about the experience is top tier. The atmosphere strikes the perfect balance between trendy & welcoming, with great music, beautiful decor, & an energy that makes you want to stay awhile.
The food is incredible, flavorful, fresh, & plated with real care. The cocktails are just as thoughtful, with a creative menu & perfectly balanced mixes. & the service? Flawless. Friendly, professional, & genuinely attentive.
Whether you're kicking off your day or heading into a night out, Benedetta delivers. Can't recommend it enough.
What can I say, Benedetta blew my expectations away! The food, to die for! The drinks, chilled & delicious! The vibe, chefs kiss! The team at Benedetta really goes above & beyond to make sure you have an unforgettable experience, & the garden terrace is beautiful… will be back for many more delicious cocktails & food
Don't go for the food! The location with the garden is beautiful but the food is overpriced. The caprese panini is only with mozarella, no basil & no tomato. So tasteless & that for 19 CAD
The pizza is no pizza, it's a ciabatta with salami or mortadella. Disappointing.
So for drinks I would return becasuse of the great ambiance but not for the food.
Jun 3, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
