Best Italian Restaurants in Westmount (2026) - Reviews & Menus

Westmount

Italian Sandwiches Breakfast Pasta Café Grill

Mentioned in: The 15 Best Salads in Montreal for a Balanced Diet

Review Summary

Reviewers consistently praise Cafe Gentile for authentic Italian flavors, fresh ingredients, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere that feels both elegant and homey. The menu earns high marks for variety and quality, with standouts from pastas and pizzas to sandwiches and brunch items, and the coffee and desserts are frequently highlighted as well. Service is described as friendly, attentive, and efficient, though a few visits note slower pacing during busy periods or larger groups. Prices are sometimes considered high for the value, but many feel the quality and presentation justify it, and the decor and vibe are repeatedly singled out as appealing. The venue is described as versatile for casual meals, business lunches, family gatherings, or special occasions, including Mother’s Day and wedding receptions, with guests often describing the experience as memorable. Overall Cafe Gentile comes across as a Montreal staple that delivers solid food, memorable atmosphere, and dependable hospitality, inviting repeat visits despite occasional inconsistencies.View restaurant profile

Order

Vago Italien

Opens Tomorrow at 12 pm

(164)

Westmount, Downtown

Italian Grill Pasta Seafood/Fish

Review Summary

Reviews describe Vago Italien as a neighborhood spot with friendly, attentive service and a welcoming vibe, where the food generally shines with strong plate presentation and standout dishes like gnocchi, though a few items such as meatballs and fried calamari have been noted as pricey for what is offered. Desserts, the wine list, and a sangria are frequently praised, and many say they would return, noting it as a good option for dinners, celebrations, or corporate gatherings. The ambiance is described as elegant and modern, sometimes lively or loud, with a private room and easy parking after hours highlighted as bonuses. Overall the impression is very favorable, with guests mentioning memorable meals, professional and personal service, and a sense of reliability that makes it a top choice for multiple visits.View restaurant profile

Order

New

Spuntino

Opens Tomorrow at 8:30 am

(30)

Westmount

Café Italian Pasta Sandwiches Salads

Review Summary

Spuntino comes across as a beloved Italian spot in the area, delivering comforting, well executed dishes that encourage repeat visits. Dishes highlighted include eggplant parmesan, truffle pasta, mushroom pasta, and pizzas, with pistachio tiramisu for dessert noted as a good choice. The atmosphere is described as charming and relaxing, with friendly service and a stylish interior, though a few reviews suggest more formal training could help. Prices are seen as high for the portions by some, while others find value for the area, and breakfast or lunch options are praised for being reasonably priced. Overall quality is consistently good and the restaurant is noted as a good fit for families and casual outings. There are occasional criticisms, such as some items not feeling wow-worthy, a couple of menu items being just okay, and ambience issues like lighting; wine prices are mentioned as steep. Accessibility concerns are raised about stairs without a railing, and during busy times service can be attentive but wait times may occur. The overall impression is a strong go-to in the neighborhood.View restaurant profile

Order

Ristorante Donato

Opens Tomorrow at 11:30 am

(280)

Westmount

Italian Pizza

Mentioned in: Burrata: The Fanciest Cheese and Where to Taste it in Montreal

Review Summary

Ristorante Donato is described as a refined Italian dining spot with a chic, modern ambiance that suits everything from business meals to special occasions. Dishes range from arancini and fennel salad to seafood specialties and pastas, with many noting flavorful, well prepared plates and highlights such as mushroom pasta, branzino, octopus, and the tiramisu. Service is frequently praised as efficient, attentive, and considerate, with staff able to adapt to guests rhythm and even offer thoughtful touches like candle desserts and prompt refills. The atmosphere is often lauded for its decor and lighting, though the space can be noisy and busy at peak times, which can affect the dining experience. Pricing and portions receive mixed feedback, with some calling prices high for the amount of food and others finding the quality and setting worth the cost. Overall, Ristorante Donato emerges as a reliable choice for high quality Italian fare, elegant design, and strong service, while visitors should be mindful of possible pacing, crowding, and price relative to portions.View restaurant profile

Donato Gelato

May be temporarily closed

(16)

Westmount

Ice Cream Italian

Review Summary

Donato Gelato is described as delivering excellent gelato with a surreal taste experience, rich and creamy and full of flavor, with many calling it the best in town and on par with the best in Italy. The cafe space is noted as clean and stylish, contributing to a welcoming and personal feel that comes from friendly staff rather than gimmicks. A variety of flavors such as pistachio, ricotta, tiramisu, lemon sorbet and dark chocolate are highlighted, though lemon is occasionally described as too sour. While price may be a bit high for a single scoop, the quality and freshness are repeatedly praised, and several reviewers say they will definitely return. Overall the impressions point to strong satisfaction, memorable flavors, and reassurance that the experience lives up to the hype.View restaurant profile

Toucheh

May be temporarily closed

(158)

Westmount

Iranian Italian Mediterranean Middle Eastern

Review Summary

At Toucheh the warm cozy atmosphere and family run service accompany a menu that blends Persian and Italian influences. The dining experience draws praise for fresh flavorful dishes and attentive staff. Diners highlight standout items such as chencheh kebabs, pastas, lentil soup, and desserts, with brunch and BYOB noted as appealing features. The atmosphere is described as welcoming and suitable for dates or casual meals, though some critics find portions for Iranian dishes smaller than expected and a few dishes not at the same level as professional kitchen cooking, along with high prices for some items. The open kitchen and busy ambiance can be a factor, and occasional reservation hiccups have occurred but were addressed. Parking can be a hassle on certain visits. Overall the restaurant is regarded as one of the better Persian options in the area, with a charming setting and a mix of flavors that invites return visits.View restaurant profile