Best American Restaurants in Pointe-Claire (2026) - Reviews & Menus

Pointe-Claire

Steakhouse Seafood/Fish American Grill Contemporary/Modern Canadian

Review Summary

Overall, reviews paint The Keg as a place with consistently excellent steaks and reliable cocktails, especially for ribeye, filet mignon, and New York strip, with sides and baked potatoes praised and the menu offering solid value for many diners. The ambiance shifts from intimate, low lighting dining to a lively bar area, and the atmosphere is often described as warm and comfortable, suitable for special occasions. Service is generally friendly and professional, with many experiences featuring attentive staff and smooth pacing, though crowded rooms can feel noisy and rushed, and timing can suffer on busy nights. A number of visits report good experiences spoiled by long waits for meals, occasional miscommunications at the bar or with reservations, and some inconsistency in cooking, with some dishes overcooked, underseasoned, or drier than expected. Overall, The Keg is viewed as a dependable go to for steak lovers, offering strong dishes and a pleasant atmosphere, while price and occasional service or kitchen hiccups remind guests that experiences can vary by location and night.View restaurant profile

Order

Nickels Deli & Bar

Open until 9 pm

(226)

Pointe-Claire

American Deli Grill Breakfast Smoked Meat

Review Summary

Nickels Deli & Bar comes across in reviews as a reliable spot for classic deli fare and smoked meat, offering generous portions and a broad menu that suits breakfast, lunch, or a casual dinner. The atmosphere is described as clean, casual, and welcoming, with friendly service that many patrons appreciate; however, a few visits mention slower pacing or inconsistency. The food tends to be praised for taste, especially the smoked meat, poutines, and other comfort dishes, while some items are noted to vary and a couple of visits report mixed experiences. Prices are generally considered fair, though a handful of comments point to higher costs or limited platter options in some contexts. Its location near the airport and in the Dorval area makes it a convenient stop for travelers and locals alike, contributing to frequent returns from regulars who value dependable flavors and a family-friendly vibe.View restaurant profile

Order

Milestones

Opens Today at 12 pm

(492)

Pointe-Claire

American Grill International Tartare Burgers

Review Summary

Milestones comes through in reviews as a vibrant, family friendly spot with a lively bar scene, generous portions, and good value, where the atmosphere and friendly, attentive service are frequently praised and the menu is seen as reliable for casual dinners, celebrations and group outings. Food is described as tasty and well prepared with a range of crowd favorites and well priced drinks, though some visits note hit or miss experiences, including slower service during busy times, occasional order mix ups, and a few dishes that arrive lukewarm or underseasoned. Several reviewers mention strong vegetarian and allergy friendly awareness, while others feel some vegetarian choices could be more flavorful. The noise level and size of the dining room can be loud, and accessibility such as parking can be challenging at times. Overall, Milestones is viewed as a dependable, welcoming option with great staff and a vibrant vibe, with most guests planning to return despite the occasional inconsistency.View restaurant profile