Best American Restaurants in Montreal-East (2026) - Reviews & Menus

Nickels Deli & Bar - American Restaurants in Montreal-East

Mercier-Hochelaga-Maisonneuve, Montreal-East

American Deli Grill Breakfast Smoked Meat

Review Summary

Overall, reviews portray Nickels Deli & Bar as a dependable neighborhood spot with generous portions and good value, serving a broad menu from smoked meat and burgers to breakfast favorites and pastas, with many noting tasty food and friendly, efficient service. The atmosphere is described as cozy or bustling depending on the time, and the staff are frequently praised for attentiveness, though a few visits mention slow moments or order errors. A recurring critique concerns seating, especially for larger or heavier guests who are steered toward small banquettes, sometimes making the experience uncomfortable during busy hours. Noise levels can be high, but the experience is often described as welcoming and family friendly, with several reviewers highlighting quick service and generous portions that justify the price. While some experiences fall short, the consensus is that Nickels offers solid dishes, sizable portions, and fair prices, making it a go-to option for breakfasts, lunches, and casual dinners, with many indicating they would return.View restaurant profile

Order

Bâton Rouge Grillhouse & Bar

Opens Today at 11:30 am

(1473)

Anjou-St-Léonard, Montreal-East

American Grill BBQ Steakhouse Salads Burgers

Review Summary

Across reviews for Bâton Rouge Grillhouse & Bar, the tone is mixed. Many diners praise friendly, attentive service and solid to excellent dishes in a welcoming, family friendly setting with easy parking, while others report a decline in cleanliness and ambiance with dirty tables, sticky surfaces and carpets, and slower, inconsistent service. Some meals are highlighted as well cooked such as steaks, seafood pastas, and ribs, but numerous comments describe ribs as dry or only partially sauced, burgers that are soggy or over sauced, and calamari that is rubbery; beverages and sides sometimes arrive underwhelming or overpriced. Several guests note being upsold from the moment they sit, and a few encounters include order mix ups or tables left uncleared, affecting the overall experience. Yet many staff members are remembered as kind, professional, and attentive, and groups report good experiences during celebrations with effective service. Overall, while the food can be delicious and service can be excellent, consistency and upkeep seem to have waned in places, leading some patrons to say they would return only if notable improvements are seen.View restaurant profile

La Cage

Opens Today at 11:30 am

(524)

Mercier-Hochelaga-Maisonneuve, Montreal-East

Grill Burgers Pub Food Sandwiches BBQ Salads

Mentioned in: The Best Sports Bars in Montreal: Where to Watch Your Favorite Games

Review Summary

La Cage is described as a lively sports bar with a big screen ambiance that makes it a go to for watching games with friends, especially for Canadiens fans. Service is frequently praised for friendliness and attentiveness, with fast, helpful staff noted, though a few visits report slower responses during busy times. The menu is broad, featuring wings, burgers, tartare, salmon, and a highly recommended Caesar salad, with some dishes earning raves (tartare, wings, salmon) and others drawing critiques (overcooked burgers, dry wings, uneven fries). Prices are considered a bit high for the quality at times, and some customers feel the kitchen can be inconsistent. Reservations and call backs can be problematic on busy nights, while the terrace and overall atmosphere are described as pleasant and social, suitable for groups and celebrations. Allergens are handled well on some visits, and the staff are noted for taking care of guests with allergies. Overall, La Cage offers a strong vibe and solid service with room for food improvements, especially when crowded.View restaurant profile