Da Emma serves traditional Roman cuisine characterized by authentic techniques and bold, simple flavor profiles. The menu focuses on artisanal pasta preparations, wood-fired roasting methods, and the integration of fresh, seasonal Mediterranean produce. Diners encounter a rustic atmosphere defined by exposed brick masonry, wooden structural elements, and vaulted ceilings that reflect a historical architectural aesthetic. Culinary offerings highlight hearty regional staples such as salt cod, artichokes prepared in the Jewish style, and robust meat dishes cooked to precise temperatures. Each selection emphasizes the fundamental qualities of high-quality ingredients sourced to maintain genuine flavor integrity. The establishment maintains a consistent focus on the culinary heritage of central Italy by providing substantial portions prepared according to generational practices. This approach ensures a direct connection to the specific food culture found in the heart of Rome.
Da Emma is widely regarded as a standout destination in Old Montreal, celebrated for its authentic Italian cuisine and remarkably atmospheric, cellar-like setting. Many diners praise the high quality of dishes such as the suckling pig, lamb, and various pastas, noting that the food often feels like a genuine home-cooked meal. While the service is frequently described as professional and friendly, opinions on the dining experience are mixed, with some visitors expressing concerns regarding noise levels, pricing, portion sizes, or inconsistency in service quality. Despite these varying perspectives, the restaurant maintains a strong reputation for providing a memorable and traditional Italian dining experience.
J'ai testé plusieurs restaurants italiens à Montréal & Da Emma était sur ma bucket list depuis longtemps. Attiré par sa réputation & les nombreux avis positifs, je peux maintenant confirmer que c'est, de loin, le meilleur restaurant italien en ville!
Ce n'est pas qu'une question de marketing: l'excellence est totalement méritée. Situé dans un bâtiment historique du Vieux-Montréal, l'endroit dégage une ambiance de cave authentique, élégante & chaleureuse. L'expérience nous transporte à un autre niveau; on se croirait carrément en Italie.
Côté cuisine, c'est exceptionnel. On sent la qualité des ingrédients dans chaque bouchée : les pâtes & la viandes goûtent la cuisine d'une véritable nonna. La viande est d'une tendreté incroyable & les pâtes sont tout simplement délicieuse.
Le service est d'un très grand professionnalisme, attentionné & jamais envahissant. On comprend vite pourquoi la réputation de l'endroit est si solide. Ma femme & moi avons vécu une soirée mémorable du début à la fin.
Je recommande fortement ce restaurant & j'y retournerai très bientôt, c'est certain!
Food was below average. We had different pastas & they were very average. Tiramisu was really bad. Service was unprofessional & slow. Overall not recommend
Feb 22, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Incroyable,ce restaurant vit sur une réputation qui n'existe plus depuis des lunes.Nourriture plus qu'ordinaire,présentation fade,le goût n'est absolument pas au rdz.Le service en bas de ce à quoi on pourrait s'attendre a ce prix,serveur qui fait le strict minimum, un hôte d'apparence négligé qui nous installe à notre table & plus intéressé a son cellulaire qu'à la clientèle.Seul point positif, la venue.Comme dissait mon bon ami Moquin,va pas là, tu va mieux manger au vieux duluth...j'aurais dû l'écouter.
We recently visited Da Emma after driving in from Ottawa, & another couple joined us from Toronto. The place itself is beautiful & has a great atmosphere, but unfortunately the food didn't quite meet our expectations.
What really disappointed us was the service. Our waiter was friendly at first, but after he made a mistake with our appetizer & we mentioned it to the first staff member we saw, he came to our table & whispered that we should have told him directly & not cut into the appetizer before knowing, which felt uncomfortable & unprofessional.
To make things worse, the police showed up at the end of the night, & when we asked for the bill to be split, the waiter seemed surprised & simply told us to split it ourselves. Overall, while the setting is lovely, the food & service left us disappointed.
Reputation surfaite! Plats garrochee , presentation mediocre , prix exagere!!! Vin de la SAQ a 4x le prix
Experience decevante pour la Saint Valentin!!
Plat de cochon de lait obliger de se battre avec avec 3 morceaux de patattes, plat de raviolis 4 pates noye dans la sauce!!
Je vais par contre donne une excellente note pour l'ambiance!
Cucina veramente Italiana al TOP, cucinata dalla Chef romana gentilissima oltre a cucinare benissimo , cibo vero italiano, ottimo. Personale molto gentile, vini ottimi, super pulito ottima location.
Lo consiglio da buon italiana.💯
Soirée parfaite du début à la fin! Nous étions deux couples avec un enfant de 3 ans, donc au premier service, & dès l'arrivée l'ambiance était excellente. Éclairage tamisé mais vivant, salle chaleureuse & agréable. La nourriture était tout simplement incroyable. Nous habitons en Italie & honnêtement, nous n'avons pas été déçus, bien au contraire, cela a largement dépassé nos attentes. L'agneau était divin, les crevettes parfaitement exécutées, & la burrata d'une qualité remarquable! Le service était à la fois super convivial & très professionnel, merci à Lucca & toute l'équipe! Aussi nous avons eu la joie de boire deux délicieux vins de la Campanie! Une adresse solide, authentique, & cohérente du début à la fin. Nous reviendrons, c'est certain.
Da Emma does not disappoint. Housed in a beautiful historic building, it sets the tone for an elevated dining experience from the moment you arrive. A wall of photos showcasing the many celebrities who've dined here underscores the legacy of this Montréal institution. Quite possibly the city's finest Italian restaurant, no small claim given the competition, it offers flawless dishes (don't miss the meatballs), attentive staff, & the bonus of complimentary valet parking. Whether you're planning a date night or celebrating a special occasion in Old Montréal, make a reservation, put on a nice outfit, & savour one of the city's must try meals.
The restaurant itself is very nice, with a romantic Old Montreal atmosphere. The food was good, & the service was generally fine. However, upon reflection, our waiter's behavior was inappropriate & made us uncomfortable.
Although Franco was soft-spoken, he constantly hovered around our table, lingering & inserting himself unnecessarily into our experience. It felt invasive & intrusive, as if he were monitoring us rather than simply providing service. This significantly detracted from what could have been an enjoyable evening.
Overall, while the setting & food were pleasant, the service left us feeling uncomfortable due to this overly intrusive behavior.
