Patrons consistently praise Broadway Pizza for delicious, NY style pizza with a crispy yet chewy crust, flavorful sauce, and well balanced cheese. The kosher options are highlighted, and many say the pizza is among the best they have tasted in Montreal or Canada. The space is described as big, clean, and inviting with a pleasant atmosphere, while service is noted to be friendly, accommodating, and efficient. Delivery is reliable and arrives on time even in challenging weather, and prices are considered affordable for the quality. The menu is praised for variety, including favorites like Sicilian slices, spicy poutine, and mozzarella sticks, with some reviews calling specific pies exceptional, such as a Pina Vodka Big City pizza. The dining experience is also described as good for family meals or quick meetings, and the overall impression is that Broadway Pizza stands out for fresh, tasty food, good value, and a welcoming vibe.
Horrible poutine the worst i had .. For the pizza she ok not great no meat on pizza .. All the good comments are from Jews so 4,5 score is a bit misleading lol .. Otherwise not worth the price.
Only the best store I've ever been to. The pizza was delicious. The workers were great & everything was phenomenal with the store & I will definitely come back. Thank you so much for the great experience.
Feb 21, 2026
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
I ordered through Uber Eats a Pie & Poutine. The driver brings me my Poutine in Bag labeled with my name & a small box which had 2 slices not mine & the box was not labeled. Had they taken the time to write my name & the other customer's name on the pizza box there wouldn't have been a mix up. Or had they taped my other order together with this i would have gotten us. I called them to ask about the mix up. Not empathy, no apology, didn't care . Will never be ordering from here again if you can't ar least call Uber & let them know they made a mix up with the order as well.
I'm from New Jersey & came here for some authentic Quebec poutine, boy was it worth the trip! nowhere in the US do they have the real poutine!
But then when I tried the pizza I'm like it's crazy I gotta come to Montreal to get actually good tasting NY style pizza this place is just something else. Now I have no choice but to make the trip even time I get a little hungry...
Oct 8, 2025
on Google
🍽️
Know where to eat in Montreal before everyone else.
Get the first look at the hottest openings, secret menus, and RestoMontreal.ca's weekly top picks. Join 50,000+ foodies.
Broadway pizza is great for family dining or a quick business meeting. The food is Delicious, quick, presented beautifully, & there is a large variety of options to choose from.
Delicious pizza with a perfectly crispy crust. The store is spacious, clean, & beautifully kept. Truly stands out from the rest. Prices are also very reasonable. Highly recommend!
Hands-down the best meal in Montreal at Broadway Pizza! Got the Pina Vodka Big City pizza - unreal flavor, perfect crust, & fresh toppings. The protein-packed dish (so good!) & French fries were crispy & delicious. Ordered a bunch of other stuff, & everything was top-notch. Service was lightning-fast - food came in seconds! The seating area is amazing, cozy, & modern. Brought my pet, & they were super welcoming. Can't recommend this place enough!
