Slice + Soda is widely praised for giant, affordable slices with a thin, crispy crust and fresh toppings that give a New York style feel in a compact, welcoming space. Reviewers note that the slices are big, fast to serve, and often satisfying as a quick bite, with classic and creative toppings like pepperoni, Margherita, veggie, carnivore, prosciutto, and a Caesar salad pairing complementing the pizza. The crust is described as airy yet crisp with a balanced sauce, and some add olive oil or chili flakes for extra kick. The open kitchen and casual, cozy ambiance, sometimes with a communal table, contribute to a neighborhood vibe that many enjoy, while seating can be limited and lines can get long on busy nights. Service is usually friendly and efficient, though a few visits mention variability in product quality or dish availability, such as reduced toppings on a later visit. Diners frequently note the value, with large slices for a reasonable price, and some call it the best pizza in Montreal or a must try, particularly for a quick meal in Old Montreal. Overall, Slice + Soda comes across as a reliable go to for a tasty, satisfyingly sized slice that pairs well with sodas and a casual, lively atmosphere.View restaurant profile
Slice + Soda is widely praised for generous NY style slices, with the pizza described as flavorful and made with quality ingredients, and the prices considered a great value. The staff are repeatedly called friendly, welcoming, and accommodating, delivering fast service even in busy times and staying warm late at night, contributing to a lively and comfortable atmosphere with music, arcade games, and a casual vibe. Many reviews highlight the size of the slices and the quality of the crust, sauce, and toppings, along with complimentary items like cookies and soda that add to the value. A common refrain is that the place is ideal for late nights after activities, with the location described as clean and the service personal rather than robotic. Some comments mention occasional delays or mix ups at the counter, and a few instances of the pizza arriving not piping hot or ready to serve, but these are outliers in an overall positive experience. Overall, Slice + Soda appears to be a top pick for pizza lovers seeking big, tasty slices, friendly service, and a fun, casual setting.View restaurant profile