Best Pizza Restaurants in Sainte-Marthe-sur-le-Lac (2026) - Reviews & Menus

Sainte-Marthe-sur-le-Lac

Review Summary

Reviews describe B.J. as a standout for generous Greek plates and excellent pizza, with pizzas that are filling, well topped, and not cheap but worth it, and travelers from Montreal saying they would go out of their way for it. Consistency is noted, with some saying the taste has not changed over the years and others crediting new management for keeping up strong recipes. People speak highly of the overall value, enjoying leftovers and a range of menu items, including takeout options. A few reviewers mention cleanliness concerns, such as insects near plates. Some mention sadness about closure or changes, yet the pizza is still praised as the best in the region. Overall, B.J. appears to be a beloved local spot for pizza with generous ingredients and quality toppings that inspires loyalty and repeat visits.View restaurant profile

Pizza Fresca

Open until 11 pm

(35)

Sainte-Marthe-sur-le-Lac

Pizza Sandwiches

Review Summary

Reviews show that Pizza Fresca delivers delicious pizza and poutine, fast delivery, and good value, with the dough described as soft and airy and toppings plentiful. Customers note friendly service, a varied menu including vegetarian options and several specialty pizzas, and many say they will order again. While the majority praise the pizza as excellent, a few mentions point to crusts that are not fully cooked and at least one complaint about a poutine container being only half full, and one reviewer suggests removing a gyro style item from the menu. Overall, Pizza Fresca is regarded as a reliable, affordable choice with strong pizza quality and quick service, especially around Sainte Marthe Sur le Lac, though occasional inconsistencies in crust and menu items appear in a minority of orders.View restaurant profile

Order

Stratos Pizzeria

Open until 10 pm

(147)

Sainte-Marthe-sur-le-Lac

Sandwiches Grill Pasta Poutine Pizza Breakfast

Review Summary

Overall, Stratos Pizzeria receives praise for its pizza and friendly service, with many calling the pizza the best in the area and the service attentive, while others note inconsistency in the kitchen and slower service at times. The poutine is a highlight for several, featuring large cheese curds, though a few reviews mention fries that taste frozen. Some dishes like lasagne and other menu items are noted as delicious, and the option to bring your own wine is appreciated. Service is described as fast and polite in some reviews, while others report slower kitchen response and longer wait times. The ambiance is described as pleasant and the staff cheerful. A recurring theme is good value and a broad menu, with room for improvement in fries quality and some items, but customers say they would return and frequently choose Stratos Pizzeria again.View restaurant profile

Order

Farsa

Opens Today at 4 pm

(93)

Sainte-Marthe-sur-le-Lac

Italian Pizza

Review Summary

Farsa receives praise for pasta with Vongole and for pizza cooked in a wood-fired oven, with many reviewers describing a home-cooked vibe and a solid wine and beer selection, though some feel the decor could use a refresh and a carpet with not ideal appearance distracted from the experience. Service is repeatedly called attentive and friendly, making guests feel like family, yet there are notes of slow service, staff unfamiliar with the menu, and occasional shortages that hamper some meals. Dishes such as Caesar salad, lasagne, salmon, linguine carbonara and parmesan fondue get strong marks, and a pistachio chicken is singled out as excellent; portions are described as generous. There are some negative moments, including an issue with hair in soup and insufficient follow-up from the owner, which left certain patrons dissatisfied. Overall, opinions range from outstanding food and welcoming vibes to inconsistencies in service and upkeep, but many would return for the food and the overall experience.View restaurant profile