Best Italian Restaurants in Sainte-Thérèse (2026) - Reviews & Menus

Sainte-Thérèse

Italian French Mussels Pasta Grill Seafood/Fish

Review Summary

Overall, reviews describe L'Académie as a welcoming spot with generous portions, solid value, and a menu that blends French and Italian influences with plenty of seafood, pasta and shareable dishes. Service is repeatedly praised as attentive and friendly, with staff anticipating needs in a busy, casual atmosphere and offering thoughtful touches like bread and timely service for groups. The bring your own wine policy and easy parking are noted advantages, though the venue can be a bit noisy at times and the pace may slow when it is crowded. While many plates are described as tasty and well presented, some items draw criticism for heavy sauces or uneven execution, and a few entrees were overcooked or not up to expectations. Still, the overall impression is positive: good food, reliable service, and value, with particular appeal for gatherings, and the menu's variety and BYOW option making it a frequent choice despite occasional inconsistencies.View restaurant profile

Ristorante Sorrento

Open until 10 pm

(195)

Sainte-Thérèse

Italian Grill Pasta Pizza

Review Summary

Ristorante Sorrento is described as a warm, cozy spot with inviting ambiance where guests praise fresh ingredients, flavorful dishes, and generous portions. Staff is frequently commended for friendly, attentive service and a homey atmosphere, though some visits note slower moments or mood shifts and opinions on ownership changes remain mixed. The menu blends Italian classics with Syrian influences, with many diners celebrating the Syrian offerings and others savoring dishes like lasagne, veal marsala, and osso buco. The option to bring own wine and a terrace on nice evenings add to the overall experience. A few criticisms appear, including meals that were not seasoned enough, overcooked meat, or value concerns related to price. Overall the consensus leans toward a memorable dinner with good service and flavorful food, encouraging repeats despite some imperfect visits.View restaurant profile

Order

Trattoria la Strada

Open until 10 pm

(76)

Sainte-Thérèse

Italian Pizza Pasta Seafood/Fish

Mentioned in: On the Hunt for Montreal's Best Cannoli

Review Summary

Reviews of Trattoria la Strada depict a warm, convivial Italian dining spot where the atmosphere and hospitality are frequently praised alongside flavorful pastas, pizzas and veal dishes. Many guests describe attentive service, a friendly and welcoming staff, and a comfortable setting that makes them feel almost transported to Italy. The food is often described as delicious and well prepared, with standouts including veal in lemon sauce, pizza crusts, and penne a la vodka, and portions that locals say offer good value. A number of comments highlight the intimate vibe and the cozy ambiance, suitable for both romantic evenings and casual meals. Some critiques mention variations in the experience, noting dishes that arrive not as hot as expected, desserts that fall short, or occasional delays at seating or in service. A few reviews mention that expectations set by online guides may not always match reality. Despite occasional hiccups, many reviewers indicate they would return and recommend the restaurant for its charm, friendly service and authentic Italian flavors.View restaurant profile

Basta Osteria

Discover the simplicity and authenticity of Italian cuisine

Open until 10:30 pm

(97)

Sainte-Thérèse

Italian Pasta Salads Seafood/Fish

Review Summary

Overall, Basta Osteria is described as an authentic Italian dining experience with house-made pasta, fresh ingredients, and dishes that arrive with balanced, comforting flavors. The menu changes every two weeks, yet staples like carbonara stay on the menu, and favorites such as octopus carpaccio and a seafood chowder appear in reviews. The ambiance is intimate, cozy, and reminiscent of a small European bistro, with a welcoming, homey vibe. Service is repeatedly praised as attentive, warm, and personal, with staff making guests feel valued and often engaging in friendly conversation. The kitchen is celebrated for its fresh pastas, including tagliatelle al ragù, and for a thoughtful wine list featuring private-imported selections. While most feedback is glowing and many call it a hidden gem, occasional notes mention busy noise or rare hiccups such as a dessert issue, all generally handled with good hospitality. Overall, it comes across as a beloved, authentic spot in Sainte Therese that draws repeat visits and strong recommendations.View restaurant profile

Reserve

Marché Theresa

Open until 7 pm

(10)

Sainte-Thérèse

Italian Pastries Pizza Desserts & Sweets

Review Summary

Marché Theresa is praised for its wide range of Italian products, with everything described as delicious and living up to the expectations of a quality Italian bakery. The staff are very courteous, pizza and cake are highlighted as especially good, and overall the reviews convey a strong recommendation.View restaurant profile