Best Italian Restaurants in La Prairie (2026) - Reviews & Menus

La Prairie

Review Summary

Villa Massimo is described as a striking venue with dense plants, wine bottles, instruments and bric a brac that can feel inviting at first but overwhelming in the crowded space. Reviews note inconsistent service, including a loud kitchen staff member who shouted at diners, which left a souring mood. The menu is long and ornate, making choices feel like a challenge. Dishes receive mixed marks: the veal scallopini is praised, while the carbonara is often noted as undercooked and not true to the classic recipe. Portions are repeatedly described as small for the price, and overall value is questioned as prices rise while quality fluctuates. Despite a beautiful setting and some positive moments in service, many reviewers say they would not return.View restaurant profile

Order

Café Lazio

Open until 3 pm - Reopens at 5 pm

(124)

La Prairie

Italian Pasta Sandwiches Pizza Café Desserts & Sweets

Review Summary

Reviews describe Café Lazio as a warm, family-run Italian home with a welcoming atmosphere, where the food is consistently delicious and portions are generous. Dishes such as pasta carbonara and grilled salmon are frequently highlighted for flavor and quality, and many notes mention fresh, homemade tasting ingredients. The service is repeatedly praised as attentive, friendly, and professional, offering helpful menu explanations and thoughtful touches that elevate celebrations and everyday meals alike. The setting is intimate with a charming character, a lively terrace in good weather, and a BYO wine policy that guests appreciate. Some tables are close together and the space can be a touch snug, but the overall experience remains highly regarded for its consistency, hospitality, and family-owned care. It's described as one of the best Italian options in the area, suitable for brunch, a casual dinner, or special occasions, with guests leaving feeling satisfied and eager to return.View restaurant profile

Order

Paolo Gattuso Ristorante

Opens Today at 4 pm

(1438)

La Prairie

Italian Pasta Seafood/Fish Pizza Salads Sandwiches

Review Summary

Paolo Gattuso Ristorante is widely praised for generous portions, a broad Italian menu, a warm atmosphere, and the option to bring your own wine, with many guests noting quick, friendly service even when busy. The cuisine is described as fresh and flavorful, with strong performances from pasta, lasagne, veal, pizza, salads, and desserts, though a few dishes and desserts have disappointed some diners. The BYOW policy is a frequent highlight that adds value, and portions are often generous for a good price. The venue suits both intimate meals and celebrations, and a cozy private room is appreciated for group events. Service is generally courteous and efficient, but there are occasional critiques of slower or less attentive service during busy times or special evenings with fixed menus. Noise can be high on peak nights, yet the atmosphere remains convivial, making it a consistent favorite for many who would return and recommend it, despite the occasional inconsistency.View restaurant profile

Les Délices de Nonna

Open until 6 pm

(6)

La Prairie

Italian Pizza Pasta Salads

Review Summary

Les Délices de Nonna is praised for incredibly delicious cannoli at an affordable price and is often described as a favorite cannoli spot. Patrons enjoy stopping by during the market for a different flavor each visit, with cannoli that are consistently fresh and delicious.View restaurant profile

Como Pizzeria

Open until 1 am

(468)

La Prairie, Brossard

Pizza Italian

Review Summary

Across reviews, Como Pizzeria is praised for a classic, generously topped pizza with a creamy cheese layer, a bold tomato sauce, and a crust described as buttery by many, making it a standout on the south shore and for some the best pizza in town. Customers note a warm, family run vibe and reliable service, with staff described as friendly and the dining experience often quick, though busy periods can bring longer waits. Many praise the menu variety, including pizzas, subs, and Italian dishes, and repeatedly cite value for money and generous portions, with the sauce and toppings highlighted as standout features. On the downside, some reviews mention changes in ingredients or consistency over time, occasional delivery or order issues, and at times pizzas arriving unsliced or not prepared for easy takeout. Parking is limited on street, with occasional access to parking behind the bank, and seating can be tight during peak hours. Taken together, Como Pizzeria comes across as a beloved local staple that delivers hearty, satisfying pizzas with strong flavor and dependable takeout or dine-in, while a few visits note room for improvement in consistency and hours.View restaurant profile

Order

Bacaro Pizzeria

Open until 10 pm

(178)

La Prairie

Italian Pizza Pasta

Review Summary

Bacaro Pizzeria receives strong praise for pizzas with fresh dough and generous toppings, along with tasty sides and desserts like Nutella beignets and cannoli, with reviewers noting high quality and flavor overall. The service is described as courteous and attentive, and the atmosphere is warm and family friendly, making it suitable for couples and groups alike. The dining experience is fast and stress free, with staff that help guests feel at home and a layout that works well for gatherings. Some feedback points to occasional misses such as lasagna being overcooked, pasta portions that could be larger, pizza sauce that could be more plentiful, and prices that feel high to some. Overall it is seen as a reliable choice for casual Italian dining with consistently tasty pizza and attentive service.View restaurant profile